The blog formerly known as   Fake Plastic Fish

January 9, 2009

Plastic, Glass, Egg Salad, & Global Warming

My lunch today… it illustrates some of the choices (or false choices) we sometimes find ourselves making where the environment is concerned.

I wanted an egg salad sandwich, but I didn’t have any mayonnaise in the house. I could have walked down to the corner store to buy some more, but there I’d be confronted with the choice of plastic or glass jars. I could have simply opted for the glass jar and been done with it, but lately, I’ve been hearing from a lot of companies about how their plastic containers are better for the environment because they weigh less and therefore require less fuel to ship.

This is true.

Plastic does weigh less than glass, and it does require less fuel to ship. Perhaps, as far as global warming is concerned, it’s the better choice. But global warming is not our only environmental concern. Plastic, as I’ve written here often, carries with it a whole host of toxicity and pollution issues. And, just as the choice to carry reusable bags makes the question of plastic vs. paper meaningless, there are options to make the question of plastic vs glass containers moot as well!

In the case of dry ingredients, we can often bring our own containers to bulk foods stores and eliminate the need for any new packaging entirely. But what about wet stuff? I have yet to see a bulk container of mayonnaise, and if I did, I think I’d be kind of scared. So, what’s the third option for mayonnaise and other wet condiments?

Make your own!

In the case of mayonnaise, this third option also happens to be really easy, as I discovered today when I whipped up a batch of homemade mayo from a recipe passed on to me by an octogenarian friend who swears she has never bought a jar of prepared mayonnaise in her life. Here are the ingredients:


1 Whole Egg
2 T. Vinegar or Lemon Juice (I used vinegar because I was out of lemons)
1/2 t. Dry Mustard
1/2 t. Salt
1 Cup Salad Oil (I used canola, but you can use any kind you want. Next time I’ll use olive oil for more flavor.)

Place egg, vinegar or lemon juice, seasonings, and 1/4 cup of the oil in the blender in the order indicated. Put on cover. Run blender until contents are thoroughly blended, about 5 seconds. Remove cover. Add remaining oil gradually and run for a few seconds after last oil is added. YIELD: About 1-1/4 cups.

IMPORTANT: Do NOT add all of the oil at once. Do not do this unless you want to waste a whole cup of oil. Remember how I said this recipe is easy? It’s super easy if you read the instructions and follow them. (Anyone have an idea for how I can use my first failed batch?) The second batch came out perfectly.

This recipe came from the instructions for my friend’s Waring blender. Next time, I’m going to try it using a wire whisk instead, as per these instructions from Epicurious.com. Less (electric) energy. Less cleanup mess.

So, here’s my mayonnaise, made from ingredients most of us already have in the house. And yes, it tastes just like the store-bought stuff. Maybe even better.

For the egg salad, I combined the mayo and eggs with Goulden’s spicy mustard from a jar we already had. But once that’s gone, I’ll try making it from scratch as well. Here’s info about making mustard from powder or seeds. Once my mustard powder in the plastic container is used up, I can replace it with bulk mustard powder or seeds from Whole Foods.

Do you have any favorite condiment recipes?

I’m grateful to the people I know were around long before this current age of convenience foods and packaging that is helping to destroy our environment. My friend makes her own mayo in the interest of frugality, not “green living.” She’s a super waste-buster. I and the polar bears thank her.

Now, a post about egg salad would not be complete without a nod to Mystery Men. Enjoy!

4 Responses to “Plastic, Glass, Egg Salad, & Global Warming”

  1. For a failed batch, start with another egg and blend in the “failure” slowly, as if it were just the oil.

    I grew up without experiencing store-bought mayonnaise. Mother always made her own in a Wesson Oil glass churn offered in the 1930s. Her secret ingredient? 1/4 t curry powder. Usually used Tarragon vinegar, as well. I have her churn, and the Wesson Oil churns are still sometimes available on Ebay. Someone else offered a churn back in the 70s, but there must be warehouses full of them somewhere as they were not a success. I believe the Joy of Cooking has a hand-whisked recipe.

  2. Hi Beth! What a great post, and I really enjoyed reading everyone else’s insight as well! The only thing that kept me from making my own homemade mayo was the salmonella risk. I’m going to try this though! Thanks for all of the inspiration and hard work! I know its not easy going plastic free, and I’m trying to purchase less! ( I have a deep love of my Tupperware, but its not just used one and thrown away) I will ban plastic zipper bags in my house once this last box is finished. There are only so many times you can wash and reuse them before they fall apart or are no longer air tight! I look forward to your posts and sharing what I’ve learned!

  3. Erin — The reusable glass bottles require fuel to transport back for refilling. As I recall, there was a study done to determine if they are more environmentally-sound than plastic, and the result was that they are only if they are reused a certain minimum number of times. But I’m sorry, I don’t remember that number. Maybe someone else could look it up?

    John — you wrote, “Zero Waste, Sustainability and Renewable Energy are my interests and these stand as good activities independent of Global Warning, true or false.” I’m with you there. And homemade egg salad is in line with those values too! 🙂

    Anonymous — Are you my dad?

    Diane — you are right. It would be nice for someone to do a definitive study of plastic vs. glass (a studied no funded by the plastic or glass industries) but minimizing all types of packaging would be helpful regardless of the results!

    ckutler — yes, like Anna’s, my vinegar and oil come in glass, and I can obtain dry mustard from a bulk bin once the plastic container is used up. But if you don’t have access to non-plastic containers, then simply buying fewer ingredients in larger sizes and mixing up condiments from scratch will cut down on the number of plastic containers over all, no?

    Anna — I am woefully behind on reading blogs, but I just checked out your tomato sauce post. What fun. I was almost ready to order my own tomato press until you mentioned the cleanup. Feh. That’s the reason I rarely use my soy milk maker.