<< Previous Post:
Next Post: >>

November 11, 2009

HP Ink Cartridge Hack: Save plastic and ink

 

This will be a short post. More of a rant, actually. And hopefully useful to at least one person out there.

Last night I discovered Hewlett Packard’s scheme to get printer owners to spend more money on ink cartridges: cartridge expiration dates.

HP printers waste ink!

I have an HP Officejet 9110 that uses ink cartridges with expiration dates actually programmed into them, causing them to stop working whether they still have ink in them or not. And when that happens, the printer itself stops working too — whether I need to use that color or not.

I don’t know if HP’s newer printers use the same kind of cartridges, but this deal irks me for multiple reasons. First, it’s a total waste of plastic and perfectly good ink to program the cartridge to expire before it’s used up. I don’t care if the cartridges can be returned to be recycled. Recycling uses more energy and resources than actually using up what we already have. And second, this is just a crappy way to get me to shell out another $40 for an ink cartridge I rarely use. (Sorry, I was up late last night doing my personal bookkeeping and realizing I need to find more ways to save money. This situation does not help!)

Fortunately, I found a work around, and maybe it could work for you too. I trick the printer into thinking the date is earlier than it is. You can change the date on the printer (on my printer, I can do it through the Maintenance menu) but that’s not enough. You actually have to change the date on the computer that the printer is connected to. Only then will it print again.

Trouble is, if you keep the incorrect date in your computer, you’ll find you have problems accessing secure web sites because the certificate dates will not be correct. So you’ll end up changing the date back and forth whenever you want to print. But you know what? I’m trying to save paper and ink by printing less often anyway, so it won’t be too much of an inconvenience.

I kick myself daily for buying this monstrous printer that is way more than I’ve ever needed. But I bought it back in the days before I became concerned about lowering my ecological footprint, and I’ve been debating the pros and cons of replacing it with a more energy-efficient printer that consumes less ink. But since I don’t use it much, I think this is a situation where keeping what I have is better than replacing it with a more eco-friendly model.

Hey, HP! I know you care about plastic pollution because you are sponsoring the Plastiki’s voyage to the Great Pacific Garbage Patch. But recycling isn’t enough. We need to be conserving resources first. So please, if you’re reading, let us know how you plan to remedy this wasteful ink situation. Please?
 



Print Print

 

<< Previous Post:
Next Post: >>

Comments

A Note about leaving comments: I switched to the LifeFyre comment system because it weeds out the hundreds of spam comments I was getting each day and also allows us to respond to individual comments, to "Like" comments, and to link them to social media if we so desire. But if you do not wish to login via social media, you don't have to. You can comment without logging in! Here's how:

  1. Type your comment in the box.
  2. Click "Post Comment As" button.
  3. When the LiveFyre box pops up, type a name, email address, and optional website address in the fields provided.
  4. Click Next.
  5. LiveFyre will ask you for a user name and password. But if you don't want to register or use a password, you don't have to. Just click "Post as Guest" which is to the left of the black "Finish" button. Your comment will be saved.
  6. Please email me if you have questions or problems. This new system is supposed to make it easier for all of us to converse, not harder.
30 comments
OHJaysonCOLE
OHJaysonCOLE

I am sure you are recycling your cartridges after use, correct? It amazes me how many cartridges are thrown away each year - a huge waste of plastic. I use compatible toner products. A place I recommend for discount toner cartridges and HP toner is http://www.tonerstore.com

Ron Ungerer
Ron Ungerer

Just found this blog when searching for a long-term hack for the expired cart issue. I'm a former HP tech (3rd party) on the laser printers - but not the inkjets... So was looking. Anyway, my C6180 MFP has an operator level over-ride at the control panel. I just got the message and had to press keys to over-ride. On the ink refill issue, when I purchased the printer about 2 years ago, I went on eBay and purchased a bulk refill system. Seven containers sit beside my printer and feed the cartridges through capillary tubes. VERY easy to refill outside of the printer, can see the ink level at a glance. FAR less expensive and less impact on the environment than the travel here - travel there - travel home more ink - more plastic -more $ - more travel to get a refill.... BTW, don't blame HP for an ink = $$ conspiracy... Their left hand has no idea what the right hand is doing - trust someone who has had to deal with them!!! Just say'n

Shaggyman
Shaggyman

I removed the CMOS battery on my HP C6180, and although none are reported as expired the printer now reports all ink cartridges are empty, and refuses to print. Ideas?

Greg Streif
Greg Streif

Anyone with HP OfficeJet 9110 and has expired cartridges (new, used but expired or those installed with remaining ink but expired), there is a way to trick the system. Open the large access panel on the left side of the unit (when you are looking at it head on), pull out the aluminum shield (this is where additional memory is located/installed) and on the lower left (beneath memory slot B's left release) is a CMOS battery. Slide the battery out and let it sit for about 15 minutes. Reinsert the battery, plug the printer's power cord and USB cable and if applicable, reinstall your old ink cartridges or install new (but expired) cartridges. You should no longer see the expired message. Do this each time you get the expired message or install expired but new cartridges.

Jim
Jim

Hey Gator fans a Cartridge World will opening after the first of the year in Gainesville ....If all goes as planned...will keep you posted

Meg
Meg

@Eleanor Howdy neighbor and go Gators! I see from your blog you're a fellow weed eater! We'll have to compare notes sometime and I'll definitely take a closer look at your blog when I have some time (and more awake brain cells).

Clif
Clif

I don't follow Thom's reasoning. He said the expiration date "protects the printing components". Since all of the printing components are contained within the cartridge itself, how does shutting it down at some date have anything to do with protection of anything except HP profit? The logic is as follows: An expiration date will make the cart useless to prevent it from possibly becoming useless. Huh? Once a cart is shut down it is useless unless the printer owner takes the time and effort to figure out how to over-ride the expiration time-out. Since this expiration date stuff is news to almost everyone, how many would know how to defeat it? This is nothing but a pain-in-the-platen for the consumer. If the customer is really who they have in mind, the default would be an inactive expiration date unless the user DELIBERATELY activated it. In that way the customer would decide on the value of having an expiration date, not HP. Want to guess how many customers would activate it. Survey says: zero.

Eleanor K. Sommer
Eleanor K. Sommer

A response to Thom Brown, the HP expert. We don't have a Staples near where I live in Gainesville FL. Office Depot discontinued its program with HP. So my plastic cartridges either go into the landfill or I send them back to HP and receive NO CREDIT for my efforts. And as I mentioned, I don't automatically get a new (PLASTIC) mailer to send them back to HP. I must make a separate online request each time I want a supply of bags. Not to mention, am I really doing anything constructive? Using a PLASTIC bag to mail back 6 cartridges for recycling?? What happens to all those plastic bags?

Beth Terry
Beth Terry

Hi Thom. Thanks so much for responding. I just knew someone from HP would want to weigh in. Here are the problems as I see them: 1) HP recycles the cartridges rather than refilling and refurbishing them. I have watched your video. In fact, I was planning on posting it in an update to this blog post a few days ago, but you beat me to it. I am sad that the cartridges are ground up to be made into new products when so much energy could be saved by simply refilling them several times. 2) I just discovered that Cartridge World can now refurbish these HP cartridges by adding a new chip to them, and they sell them at a fraction of the cost. Why can't HP do the same thing? 3) You cartridges are mad expensive. I should have checked on the cost before buying this unit, but what's done is done an I have a feeling the environmental impact of replacing the printer would be greater than buying a new more efficient one with less expensive cartridges. 4) Like I said, I know that HP cares about the environment, but I also feel like the company is putting profits before people and planet when it comes to the bottom line. 5) This is not the first time I've had issues with an HP product. Please read my post about my frustrating experience with an HP monitor: http://fakeplasticfish.com/2008/02/week-35-results-501-oz-of-plastic-waste/ Beth .-= Beth Terry´s last blog ..Say No to Fake Plastic Wishbones & Other Thanksgiving Waste =-.

Thom_SoCal_HP
Thom_SoCal_HP

Hi Beth – HP ink expert here! You raise a lot of good questions, but I just want to set the record straight on a few points. Only a very small percentage of HP ink cartridges use expiration dates and this is absolutely not a “scheme” to force customers into purchasing more ink. It’s actually a mechanism that protects the printing components, as ink ages and its properties change over time. Although the majority of customers can manually override the expiry date with minimal impact on their printing experience, it looks as though your printer does not allow this function. Want to know more? The HP Learn About Supplies http://bit.ly/3EqRGA site lists the printers and cartridges affected by this. I also want to point out that HP is the only printer manufacturer with a “closed-loop” http://bit.ly/10MImv inkjet cartridge recycling process that “up-cycles” plastic from empty cartridges, returned through HP Planet Partners, and combines it with other sources of recycled plastic to create brand new print cartridges. HP has also partnered with Staples so customers can return their empties to any retail location and receive a $3 credit. This short video, “How Green Is Your Print Cartridge?” http://bit.ly/1LNRij should give you a better idea of how committed HP is to reducing the environmental impact of printing. Hope this info helps! Thanks, Thom Brown HP follow me - Thom_SoCal_HP

Aaron shaw phd
Aaron shaw phd

I am so happy for a site like this! .-= Aaron shaw phd´s last blog ..Baby Animal of the Day! Lemur! =-.

James Kennedy
James Kennedy

I have been looking around the internet and can only find a chip resetter for epson printers (what I have), but apparently there is a battery within your printer which is for the CMOS If you can find this and remove it for it about an hour, the CMOS is reset and you can continue to use the cartridge, if this doesn't work, maybe try printing with the battery removed. It is also worth noting you can buy refill kits for cartridges.

Stephanie
Stephanie

Totally off-topic: I followed your blog briefly, haven't been by for a long time, and yet... You still influence the way I think about my consumption. Never met you, hardly read you, but I think of you often ;). Just wanted to let you know you're making a difference in my thought pattern, and there are probably other lurkers who take a bit of you with them to the supermarket, the deli, the mall... In short, thanks for your efforts.

Beth Terry
Beth Terry

@James, that's great to know. I'll see if I can find a program to change the data on the chip instead of constantly having to change the date on my computer. About flushing cat litter: I agree that most people should probably not flush their cats' poop of the cat goes outside. But our cats have always been indoor cats. They never go outside so never have a chance to pick up toxoplasma gondii. In fact, when we first got them, we had them tested for the parasite to make sure they didn't have it, and a representative from a sea otter protection group (I would have to look up the name of the person) confirmed that if they test negative and then stay inside, they won't get it. So we feel comfortable flushing our cat litter, but I don't recommend others do it unless they have the same situation we do. @Eleanor Great idea! Would you mind posting that information in the "Citizen Action" section of the Disussion Board? http://fakeplasticfish.com/discuss/forum/citizen-action .-= Beth Terry´s last blog ..Jackson Browne: Defiant About Bottled Water =-.

Chelsea
Chelsea

I hate printer's making you buy so much ink. You might check with Cartridge World if there is one near you about a used more efficient printer. The one near me has older printers that still print fine and are more ink efficient then the new ones that they sell from time to time.

Eleanor Sommer
Eleanor Sommer

HP's ink jet policies have made me irate for years. I must write to the company regularly for recycle bags to send the spent cartridges back to the company. (They will not automatically send me one when I send back cartridges, I must go online and order more!) Stores used to accept the spent cartridges, but that program was canceled. I, too, have found that the entire system shuts down when one color cartridge is out of ink. I can't even print in black, if one of the color cartridges is spent. I don't print in color often but it seemed that I was always running out of color ink; then a salesperson at a local store told me this: If you don't use the ink often enough, it dries up!! Which indicates to the sensors that it is OUT of ink. He said the simple solution to that is to print a color copy about once a week, just to stir up the ink. I have written two letters to the HP CEO about their decidedly anti-environmental and wasteful approach to home printing. As they just about corner the market on reasonably priced home printers, I suggest we mount a campaign to encourage to change design and also to make it easy for customers to recycle cartridges. Here's the address: Mark Hurd CEO and President Hewlett-Packard Company 3000 Hanover Street Palo Alto, CA 94304-1185 USA .-= Eleanor Sommer´s last blog ..Herbs Without Patents =-.

James Kennedy
James Kennedy

Hi, I like this blog, very interesting and informative and I am writing from Norway. Just a quick few comments on this post and a previous one. For ink jet cartridges with chips, it is possible to download free programs which can alter the information on the chip, or simply stop the computer sending data to the chip. It all depends on your type of printer and what . Some internet searches should find what you you can do. On an earlier post I was having a look at on cat litter. I noticed some mentions of flushable cat litter and also that some people train their cat to use a human toilet. I don't recommend this as cat faeces can contain a parasite called Toxoplasma gondii which they can pick up from eating infected birds, rats etc. Most sewage treatment plants are not equipped to deal with this parasite as it is generally not found in human faeces. This parasite then ends up being discharged with treated sewage and can infect other wildlife particularly otters. I hope you take this into consideration with your cat litter issues.

Anna @Green Talk
Anna @Green Talk

I have this same problem. I had bought a bunch of cartridges over the years and now the HP won't work. I tried their work around and nothing happened. It is on my to do list to call them. I have 4 cartridges that don't work now. How stupid... .-= Anna @Green Talk´s last blog ..InStyleBelly: Pregnancy Consignment with an Eco Chic Attitude =-.

Amber
Amber

We ran into this with our HP printer recently, following a power outage. I think it somehow confused things. I'm not sure, in fact, whether it resolved itself once everything was reset to the correct date or not. Either way, how annoying and wasteful! Come on, HP, get with it and stop gouging us. Not. Cool. And also? Not. Sustainable. .-= Amber´s last blog ..Never Again =-.

Nick Palmer
Nick Palmer

The manufacturers have to find some way of forcing us to buy lots of expensive ink even though it only costs them pennies to make because they sell the printer at cost or below cost to get the initial sale - relying on people's inertia to prevent them kicking up a fuss. This is the famous razor blade/shaver model of marketing. It makes more waste and it ultimately costs us more. I think this model of marketing products should be taxed out of existence if we are ever to get a sustainable way of living going. Nick Palmer On the side of the Planet - and the people - because they're worth it Blogspot - Sustainability and stuff according to Nick Palmer http://nickpalmer.blogspot.com .-= Nick Palmer´s last blog ..Because it's there. =-.

Beth Terry
Beth Terry

Regarding refilling: I should have mentioned that the other thing that sucks about my cartridges is that they can't be refilled because of the electronic chip embedded in them. At least that is what they told me at Cartridge World when I tried to refill them several years ago. I think HP makes them unrefillable on purpose. And also, refilling will not solve the problem of the cartridges expiring before they are even empty. .-= Beth Terry´s last blog ..Baking Soda: So Many Uses; So Little Money… and Plastic =-.

Daddy
Daddy

Last week I received a mailer from Costco (big plastic land), advertising a new service at the photo desk. They now refill cartridges for under $10. Check it out.

Martin
Martin

The printer was one of a handful of things that got left behind during our most recent move, We were going the refill route, which may have saved a bit of plastic but it was mostly about money, The money we pay when we occasionally have to get something printed out by a service provider has probably been a lot less than the price of a cheap printer, You know that little save the trees message at the bottom of some emails? We really should think twice about every printing job. A pet peeve of mine if that the young people at the copier service say they can't print selected pages of a pdf. There should be software to make that easy to do and everybody that has a printer should have it, .-= Martin´s last blog ..How Many Times Do You Use a Razor Blade? =-.

Clif
Clif

I know there are millions out there who sympathize. I do. I knew about the date thing but if you buy a new cartridge the date is far enough in the future that you can refill several times before it arrives. I bought a refill kit at Office Depot that works fine and gives me many (black ink) refills for about $20 - a huge savings over buying new carts. Kodak is marketing a line of printers that have the ink-jet mechanism in the printer so you buy only a simple dumb tank of ink that costs less than the HP design (but is still a plastic problem). One thing probably everyone knows is to ignore the "almost out of ink" warning that pops up. I've found I can still print dozens of sheets after seeing that warning before the ink really runs out. I use the low ink warning as a prompt to refill. The ink-jet market is a God-send for HP...sell the machine dirt cheap then sit back and clean up on the cartridges....but don't forget to keep coming up with new machines that need a slightly different cartridge design, so you can head off the refill market.

Meg
Meg

Thanks for writing about this! I didn't know HP was doing this, but now I'll definitely make sure any printers I buy in the future do not do this! I suspect they came out with this "feature" primarily to stop people from refilling printer cartridges. What a shame! I can understand them wanting to make more money, but going to these lengths to stop people from choosing the more environmentally sound option? They won't get another cent from me while they're pulling this crap!

Canada Guy
Canada Guy

Buy a laser printer! You can get these for $99 or less today and a full cartridge can print 5000 pages. I still have a laser printer I bought over 10 years ago and I still haven't put in the spare toner I bought at the time. :) Mind you, I don't print a lot. Inkjet printers are way too wasteful, laser is much better, and even cheaper. You might have to pay a bit more for the printer, but'll you'll save hundreds in ink over the years. .-= Canada Guy´s last blog ..Low Hanging Fruit =-.

Beth Terry
Beth Terry

Shaggyman, I wish I could answer your question about the printer, but I'm not really a tech person, and in fact, I couldn't even find the CMOS battery on my printer! But switching to Cartridge World refilled cartridges has seemed to have helped. My ink cartridges always appear empty, but the printer will print anyway. No idea why it works, but it does. Stacy, that sucks about Staples. Have you looked into Cartridge World refills? They are way less expensive than the tiny discount you get from Staples.

Post Popularity Graphing by Knowledge Ring