The blog formerly known as   Fake Plastic Fish
July 24, 2007

Plastic Microbeads in Facial Scrubs — We’re Flushing Plastic Down the Drain!

06/10/2013 Update:  Several organizations have waged a campaign to get companies to eliminate polyethylene micro-beads from their facial scrubs.  Please read my updated post to take action and learn about what other kinds of products contain microplastics.

Here is the text of my original article from July of 2007, which was updated in December 2011:

Say what? The little grains in exfoliating scrubs more often than not are made of plastic these days! Plastic that is meant to be rinsed down the drain, where it enters our waterways and the bodies of aquatic creatures. I almost didn’t believe it when I read it in this article: Polymers Are Forever. So I did a Google search, and this is what I found…

MD Formulations Face & Body Scrub contains polyethylene granules.
Peter Thomas Roth AHA/BHA Face & Body Polish contains micro-fine polyethylene beads.
SkinCeuticals Body Polish contains polyethylene beads.
Helen Pensanti Exfoliating Cleanser contains polyethylene beads from Switzerland. (Do the Swiss make better plastic?)
Isomers Manual Microderm Cleanser contains polyethylene beads.

Thinking that it was just the high-end cleansers that contain plastic, I went to drugstore.com and did a search on “polyethylene.” There were over a thousand items that contained “polyethylene” in the ingredients list! (12/07/2011:  Since this post was first published, Drugstore.com has changed its Search function so you can no longer see all the products that contain a particular ingredient.) Among the facial scrubs containing plastic were pretty much anything described as having “microbeads,” such as:

Dove Gentle Exfoliating Foaming Facial Cleanser
Nivea face scrub
Aveeno daily scrub
Neutrogena Body Clear body scrub
L’Oreal Pure Zone Pore Unclogging Scrub Cleanser
Ambi Even & Clear Skincare, Exfoliating Wash
Clean & Clear Oil-Free Daily Pore Cleanser
Phisoderm Nurturing Facial Polish
Garnier Nutritioniste Nuti-Pure Microbead Cream Scrub

So how about some good news? Here are some facial scrubs on the drugtore.com web site which do not contain polyethylene. Several of these are labeled as 100% biodegradable.

Alba Botanica Clarifying Scrub
Alba Hawaiian Facial Scrub, Pineapple Enzyme
Aubrey Organics North Woods Face Scrub
Avalon Organics Exfoliating Enzyme Scrub
Burt’s Bees Citrus Facial Scrub
Burt’s Bees Peach & Willowbark, Deep Pore Scrub
derma e Microdermabrasion Scrub
Earth Science Gentle Facial Scrub, Apricot
Grandpa’s Old Fashioned Oatmeal Soap, For Face & Bath
Jason Natural Cosmetics Scrubble (various types)
Jason Red Elements Exfoliating Scrub
Juice Organics New! Apple Exfoliating Peel
Kiss My Face Organics Jump Start, Exfoliating Face Wash
Kiss My Face Organics So Refined, Jojoba & Mint Facial
Nature’s Gate Revitalizing Facial Scrub
Zia Natural Skincare Natural Microdermabrasion Scrub

So the moral to the story is: Read labels! You might be buying more plastic than just the container!

63 comments
BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

So apparently you think your disease ridden water is being directly flushed in to streams and oceans? You're naivete to the subject at hand is cute.


All gray water in city areas goes to sewage processing plants that filters anything other than water out of our water.


If you live in the middle of nowhere, the septic tank does the same thing.



rachel
rachel

I have an aveeno face scrub with particles labeled microcrystalline wax. Is that the same thing?


teaandolive
teaandolive

The issue isn't whether it is good or bad for your skin, people. The issue is that it is bad for the environment. Period.

teaandolive
teaandolive

The issue isn't whether it is good or bad for your skin, people. The issue is that it is bad for the environment. Period.

Mart
Mart

I would like to ask something, before everyone eliminates these beads, how did they get there. Last time I checked sewage should not be getting into our waters and if it is then we have a bigger problem than these beads. I have a feeling else is going on and would not jump to conclusions especially for the rinse off products.

Jo
Jo

Great work, Beth! I saw your TEDs and was very impressed with your initiative and achievements. I'm starting to work on this marine litter subject and fortunatelly it's becoming well disseminated. Not so well known, however, if the impact microplastics can have and scientists are only recently strating to understand how these particles are entering the food-web. Addressing the issue above regarding the waste water treatment plants, most systems will unlikely remove these tiny particles (some peer-reviewed articles have discussed it) an therefore it is expected that most of our exfoliating residues will end in rivers and seas. This is totally unnecessary, as there are so many alternatives to plastic microspheres, as you so well exemplified. Here's a recently created petition on the subject: http://www.change.org/petitions/cosmetic-manufacturers-stop-contributing-to-marine-plastic-pollution-with-your-exfoliating-scrubs It would be great if you could disseminate it among like-minded people. Best wishes

Pavlina
Pavlina

Doesn't the water treatment facility remove this from the treated water?

carlamoffatt
carlamoffatt

Don't forget about Dermadoctor KP Duty body scrub. Its exfoliant is polyethylene beads.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Just discovered your blog, it´s great. I read ´The World Without Us´ while on holiday and got very upset about the small plastic beads in body scrubs, so I am pleased to see that the message is getting out. What do the manufacturers of these products have to say about this matter? Shouldn´t there be some sort of ban on their use?Thanks Beth for such a good blogSue Jones

Him
Him

I'm so glad to find this post. I've been using one of the plastic-containing brands, and I had no idea. The concept that I'm washing my face with plastic that will go down the drain and stay in our environment -- argh! I'm going to try one of the alternatives mentioned in your blog or the comments. Thanks for sharing this information.

Fake Plastic Fish
Fake Plastic Fish

Hi GuamGal. It doesn't look like it's got plastic in it. I think the moisture beads are made from gelatin. The things that have plastic are exfolliating scrubs that feel rough on your skin.That said, there are some worrisome ingredients in the bodywash. For one thing, the label lists "fragrance," which probably means phthalates. Check out my post about Pure & Natural soap for more info about fragrance and phthalates:http://www.fakeplasticfish.com/2008/06/pure-natural-is-just-name-not.htmlBeth

GuamGal
GuamGal

I bought some Softsoap bodywash with moisture beads. http://www.drugstore.com/products/prod.asp?pid=165899&catid=64337The label doesn't list polyethylene, but I'm wondering if those moisture beads are of the same stuff, or if they dissolve. Can you help me?Thanks for an awesome blog! I live on Guam so the firsthand effects of what we toss in the water (with intent and otherwise) are especially clear to me.

Allie
Allie

This is revolting! It's so unnecessary!

Anonymous
Anonymous

MyChelles "incredible pumpkin peel" is a glorious way to exfoliate, especially if like me one has sensitive skin; it exfoliates helps cellular turnover and truly leaves my face smooth and soft, doesn't dry out at all! I wish more of the world were as conscious as this gem of an article merci

christyb
christyb

I accidentally posted anonymously but I asked the question about what to do with product that I have...Throwing it away would mean throwing away a 32oz. recyclable plastic bottle as well as the plastic pump and stem. I could empty the bottle into something - I fear that just putting it in the trash it will end up in the soil and still pollute.I hate these kind of conundrums! This reminds me of most elections - which is the lesser of the two evils choice?!

Fake Plastic Fish
Fake Plastic Fish

Dear anonymous professional esthetician, please reread the article. It is not about whether or not polyethylene beads are safe for the face. It's whether or not flushing them down the drain is safe for our oceans and eco-system. Plastic accumulates toxins in the environment and enters the food chain. Please do some more reading about this issue. The article, Plastic Ocean, on my left sidebar is a great place to start.

Anonymous
Anonymous

As a professional esthetician polyethelyne beads are safe. They do not enter the peidermis at all, they are rounded with soft edges so no micro-tears on the epidermis like the apricot scrubs (which are never to be used on the face - ever!)- yes I know they saw that on the package - NEVER ON THE FACE!!! Micro tears intot he epidermis (if you were to look at the skin under a microscope). These micro tears allow bacteria (good and bad to enter the skin). Polyethelyne beads don't sound so bad after all do they? Have a nice day ladies!

Fake Plastic Fish
Fake Plastic Fish

Hi Anonymous. What to do with the unused product? I think in this case it would probably do less harm in a landfill than being allowed to flush down the drain. You don't want to add more plastic to our waterways. Anyone else have a different opinion?

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@BristolDavidson your confidence in conventional water treatment plants and in your own limited knowledge is astounding! If the experts were as confident as you why would there be so much research into water contamination including by the CSIRO? Google 'contaminants in treated waste water' and begin reading up on scholarly material for studies and testing done on groundwater, surface water, and yes drinking water.  


Conventional STPs are designed to filter out gross solids eg. shit from the toilet and debris that has made it's way down the sink.. Filtration is not adequate, even at the level of grit eg. sand.  Septic tank systems treat domestic waste water by sedimentation and anaerobic decomposition of sludge.  


The point is our domestic waste is no good for living creatures to consume.  No matter what system you are using everything you pour down the sink immediately becomes an environmental problem including pharmaceuticals, cleaning products, personal care products, and coffee. The behaviour of households over the last ten years has changed dramatically due to greater consumption of a range of products.  Product selection impacts our waste water and our waterways.  Ironically, the fact we now understand how precious water is, maybe simply because it costs more, means we have shorter showers, turn off the tap sooner, and divert grey water in some cases. This actually leads to higher concentrations of toxins entering STPs (treatment systems).  Micro plastics are being found in large waterways around the world.  Take Lake Erie for example had the highest density, averaging somewhere around 80,000 particles of microplastic per km2.  Micro-plastic particles, defined here as particles of less than 5mm in size, can arise through four separate processes:

  1. deterioration of larger plastic fragments;
  2. direct release of micro particles into waterways and via wastewater treatment;
  3. accidental loss of industrial raw materials during transport or trans-shipment, at sea or into surface waterways;
  4. discharge of sewage.  

No matter how you look at it, pouring plastic down the drain is a very very bad idea, and simply doesn't need to happen at all. By the way don't forget caffeine is also a contaminant that finds it's way into streams and rivers.  Tipping coffee grounds on the garden is much better!

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@teaandolive your naivete is showing - the water must be processed at a treatment facility REMOVING ALL POLLUTANTS  (be it paper, urine, faeces, and yes...even plastic) from the water before it reaches the "environment".   septic tanks with field lines do the same thing. 

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@Mart yes Mart there are bigger problems than micro beads getting into waterways. but then again just how big a problem is plastic in the oceans? How do they get there. good question.  numerous ways including via sewage.  this is just one of many contaminants having a catastrophic effect on our eco systems.  we like to think we can just pluck anything packaged to look awesome on the supermarket shelf , chuck the remainders down the sink or into the landfill rubbish bag and we won't ever have to worry about it.  think again!

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@Joy Gallary If they are to tiny for the filters, then explain why disease isn't more rampant due to water?


Derp. 



Beth Terry
Beth Terry

Thanks, Jo. I signed and linked on Facebook.

Beth Terry
Beth Terry

Hi Pavlina, that's a good question. But even if it's true, what happens with the plastic beads that are removed? They still end up in the environment.

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@Him Your computer is plastic.  Everyone freak out!

anonymous
anonymous

@Fake Plastic Fish acrylates copolymer isn't plastic? my bottle of softsoap with moisture beads has that in it and I am disappointed to think that I need to throw it out.

anonymous
anonymous

@GuamGal, @Fake Plastic Fish my bottle of softsoap with moisture beads includes the ingredient "acrylates copolymer"... isn't that plastic?

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@Allie internet is so revolting and unnecessary, i see you are still using it though?

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@christyb Oh geez.  Here's an idea:  use your product. Then up cycle the bottle?


So naive.  Cute.

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@Fake Plastic Fish in a landfill - the water is not sewage treated.


down the drain the filters catch everything that is not water.  (Yep, even germs.)


Don't believe the hype.  Use your brain. 

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@BristolDavidson @teaandolive wrong Mr BristolDavidson aka Troll, your lack of information is showing.  Not ALL contaminants are removed from ALL STPs.  It depends how expensive the STP is and what toxins you are talking about.  Often waste water is released into water ways to further break down there.  That is why the Government asks industry to comply with standards and reduce toxins and for domestic householders to 

"Never put harmful substances down sinks, toilets or stormwater drains:

  • Substances including petrol, grease, oil, pesticides and herbicides, and solvents such as paint strippers should not be poured down sinks, toilets or stormwater drains. These substances are difficult to remove in the sewage treatment process and cause pollution problems in our local waterways."

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@BristolDavidson because loads of chemicals are added such as chlorine, to kill bacteria (again depedning what the plant can afford)   However, some do get through and cause illness eg. Giardia (10 to 100 cysts/L detected in treated water and 10 or few cysts/L in surface water sources and tap water) ... and Mr troll chlorine does not break down plastics.  There are other compounds that persist in water after treatment at DWTs including pharmaceuticals.  .. "prescription and non-prescription drugs and their metabolites, fragrance compounds, flame retardants and plasticizers, cosmetic compounds, and a solvent. The detection of these compounds suggests that they resist removal through conventional water-treatment processes"  http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969704001937

Google it dude.  Go learn something new.   


BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@Joy Gallary If that was fact  - it is not -  then germs, disease, and viruses would be spreading through showers.



BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@Beth Terry Aparently you've never heard of this awesome novel idea called "recycling".


So, no they don't "end up in the environment".  They end up in carpet.

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@BristolDavidson Thankfully there are many companies who take this issue a lot more seriously than you, eg. Fuji Xerox, who have been re-manufacturing and working to include far more bio-plastics in their office equipment.  Re-manufacturing is becoming essential.  Computer upgrades now include removal of your superseded models to be dismantled and re-used.  However, huge amounts of e-waste still find their way to third world countries where children live and work in toxic pits trying to salvage anything with re-sale value.  it's no laughing matter.

BristolDavidson
BristolDavidson

@anonymous Isnt throwing an entire bottle of undiluted soap with beads just as bad  - if not worse because it cant biodegrade? 

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@BristolDavidson ive already answered this but germs do survive treatment and go on to cause illness from time to time. The reason it doesn't happen more often is because treatment plants use chemicals that kill most bacteria.  We then drink those chemicals if we drink town water.  However, these anti-bacterial treatments do not remove all toxins and contaminants.  Many persist in water after treatment. 

Joy Gallary
Joy Gallary

@BristolDavidson No wrong again.  If any little plastic beads are present in the sludge from septic, or in the effluent from conventional waste water its just a bi product, another waste problem.  it is not a recycling facility it's a water treatment facility.  if you want to contribute to recycling you need to put the plastic into the recycling bin, or drop it at a recycling facility.  Plastic micro beads are not recyclable with current equipment.

Trackbacks

  1. […] 32 Persoonlijke verzorging In sommige verzorgingsproducten zit er plastiek dat je gewoon doorspoelt. Kijk zeker eens op het etiket. http://fakeplasticfish.com/2007/07/flushing-plastic-down-drain/ […]

  2. […] http://myplasticfreelife.com/2007/07/flushing-plastic-down-drain/ Share this:EmailMoreFacebookTwitterLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. This entry was […]