The blog formerly known as   Fake Plastic Fish

October 23, 2008

Skoy cloths: they’re plastic-free and save many, many paper towels.

I gave up paper towels when I first went plastic-free since all brands come wrapped in plastic. Later, I realized how wasteful the whole idea of paper towels is in the first place. So I switched to natural cellulose sponges and cut-up rags. (Microfiber cloths are a no-no for the plastic-free crowd because they’re made from… uh… plastic.)

The thing is, sponges get gross and don’t dry out quickly, so they tend to smell bad after a while. And the rags I was using weren’t particularly absorbent. Then, a few weeks ago, I read about Skoy cloths on the Crunchy Domestic Goddess blog, and thought they sounded like a great idea.

Skoy cloths* are 100% biodegradable, as they’re made from cotton and cellulose. They’re also chlorine-free and contain water-based colors and inks. While highly absorbent like sponges, they are thin and dry out fast. The company claims that one Skoy cloth can replace 15 rolls of paper towels and can last for over a year. I guess it depends on how often you use paper towels. I don’t think I’ve gone through that many in my lifetime. But then, I wasn’t counting.

Anyway, I emailed the company and asked for a sample. But not, of course, before asking about the packaging. Guess what! Zero plastic. They come packaged just as you see in the picture, with a simple cardboard strip holding the 4-pack together. And in fact, Michelle Lundqvist, who sent the cloths to me, said, “We really tried hard to find a way to package without plastic.”

So far, Michael and I are really pleased with the cloths. (Well, I should say Michael is, since he does most of the actual cleaning. What a guy!) The fact that they last such a long time (washable in dishwasher or washing machine and microwavable when wet) and can be composted at the end of their lives makes them nearly perfect.

Nearly? Well, the web site says they’re made from “natural cotton” rather than organic cotton. Perhaps we could ask Skoy to create an organic version. A 4-pack of regular Skoy cloths costs $5.99. Would you pay more for organic?

Have you tried Skoy cloths*? And if so, what do you think?

10/27/08 Update: One FPF reader mentioned Twist Cloths, which are sold at Whole Foods. First of all, Twist cloths are packaged in plastic, while Skoy cloths are not. To find out other differences, I emailed Skoy, and this is Michelle’s response:

Beth, We welcome you to try the difference between Twist and Skoy. We think Skoy will be the winner. It is a superior product and below defines that.

The differences between Skoy and Twist:

1. SKOY is made of cotton and cellulose and Twist is cellulose only (cotton net). This gives SKOY a rag-like feel rather than sponge-like.
2. Twist’s products are made in China and SKOY in Germany. Our factory is leaps and bounds above on environmental awareness.
3. Twist’s sponges are packed wet – feel free to investigate wetting/antibacterial agents in sponges and you will see the harmful effects to the environment. SKOY uses no antibacterial agent or wetting agent.
4. SKOY is washer and dryer safe and Twist instructs not to put in dryer.
5. SKOY has fun designs, Twist does not
6 SKOY has a full range of colors making SKOY more modern and fashionable.
8. SKOY uses no plastic in packaging, only recyclable paper.

Personally, I don’t care about colors and designs, but some of the other differences are very interesting to me!

18 Responses to “Skoy cloths: they’re plastic-free and save many, many paper towels.”

  1. No plastic, great. Ships from Amazon… um, that’s not a zero pastic shopping experience. If we’re going to focus on improving our environment, we should start by boycotting the corporate giants with the largest footprints…

  2. I use paper towels to blot dry meat or fish before pan frying it — what could I use for that instead? Would cotton rags do the job?

  3. A note from Europe – Amazon sells Skoy 4 cloths at a price of over 15 dollars excluding shipping! I use knitted cotton cloths as much as I can – but they sound great!

  4. My dad is very waste-conscious mostly for the sake of being frugal, and I don’t think he uses paper towels at all. To clean up after cats he uses a dustpan and rubber gloves (I’m not sure if he uses the gloves to get the stuff onto the dustpan) to get rid of the 3 dimensional part and then cleans up with soapy water and a mop or rag. I always thought it was a little gross but he does clean up the dustpan and everything so it shouldn’t be a safety concern.

    • I would use a Skoy cloth to clean up cat vomit. They rinse out really well. But for something like poop… I use toilet paper. 🙂

  5. Hi, dshaw1221. The impact of the disposable towel is not simply from its end of life but from production as well. Paper requires a lot of water to produce. And paper towels come packaged in plastic, which is made from all kinds of nasty chemicals and pollutes the air and water when it’s manufactured. So as long as you use a reusable product enough times to make up for its production costs, it will come out ahead.

  6. While traveling in New Zealand a few years ago I got converted to cotton dish cloths (they look like wash cloths, but are for dishes…you just throw them in the washing machine when they need cleaning), Shortly after, a relative gave me a woolen crochet dish cloth (very open crochet style)…it’s great! Dries really quickly and doesn’t get smelly.

  7. Hi Beth! Michelle here from Skoy – just checked back and read some comments. Two things. Twist sponge cloth is made in China – they have one product made in Mexico and try to use that as where “all” their products are made. I am sorry about the plastic from Amazon, but when we found out – we contacted them and explained the importance of no plastic and now they are shipping plastic-free. All my best…

  8. Hi. As I recall, Twist does come in plastic packaging. But double check. Also, someone told me that she ordered Skoy cloths through Amazon and they came packaged in plastic. But if you get them directly from Skoy, there is no plastic.

  9. thinking about switching to skoy. if i remember right, the twist loofah sponge i buy does not come in plastic packaging.

    for materials used, i’m not sure which one is better.

    for production process, based on skoy’s claim, they win.

    “2. Twist’s products are made in China and SKOY in Germany. Our factory is leaps and bounds above on environmental awareness.”

    correction, from what i see on the web, twist is made in mexico. and they try to support their workers. from a workers right stand point, Germany has a stronger record.

    from resources used in shipping from factory to usa, looks like twist wins.

    i’ll probably go with skoy based on German worker’s rights and claims about cleaner production method.

  10. A friend (thanks MaryAnne) sent one of these great cloths home with my husband from church… (to say the angels sang “Alleluiah” would be lyin’, and just because I’m not Catholic, doesn’t meant that I don’t still wanna go to heaven) … BUT I did love it, and I will keep passing on the great news of this product!

  11. Hey Kim. I suggest you email Michelle at Skoy and ask her your question. She’s really nice and responsive. She might have a solution for you.

    michelle[at]skoycloth[dot]com

  12. Hi Kim. You can put Skoy cloths in the dishwasher. I’m wondering if that would be better than the laundry since the dishwasher already contains greasy dishes? You could also keep a bucket of soapy water for soaking them beforehand.

  13. Hi Lauren. Don’t know if they’re the same, but I do know that the ones at Whole Foods come wrapped in plastic.