The blog formerly known as   Fake Plastic Fish
August 9, 2012

Coloring Hair with Henna: Non-toxic and Almost Plastic-free

I don’t color my hair often, mainly because I’m lazy and don’t want to take the time to do it. But once a year, when it’s time for the annual BlogHer conference estrogen fest, I feel the need to cover my graying temples that make me look older than I feel.

 

(It’s also the time I get my annual pedicure and clean up my crazy eyebrows with homemade sugar wax.) But hair dyes are pretty toxic — even the “natural” ones — and all come in plastic packaging. For a while, I would go to a salon and use the “Don’t ask; don’t tell” method of living plastic-free. If I didn’t see a plastic bottle, it didn’t exist. Clearly, that was cheating.

 

So I was very happy when I discovered that I could buy henna (which is about as safe as it gets) with less plastic packaging and that it would actually cover my gray! [Note: Your mileage may vary. I’m only gray at the temples so far. I don’t know how it would work on an entire gray head.  Please leave a comment if you have tried it.]  I tried two different brands:

BULK RAINBOW HENNA

I found Rainbow brand henna in bulk at Rainbow Grocery (no relation, as far as I know) in San Francisco.  I filled up a reused paper bag (I reuse paper bags until they fall apart and then I compost them).   Yes, the henna is stored in a big plastic container, but as I’ve said before, buying in bulk generates much less plastic waste than buying smaller sized containers, even if the bulk bag or container is plastic.

 

I bought the dark brown color and followed the directions for gray hair on the Rainbow Research website, adding brewed black coffee for a darker color and apple cider vinegar, which is supposed to help the color hold onto grey hair.  (See the website for exact measurements and recipes for other colors.)  I also added some ground clove, at the suggestion of Michael’s sister, and it made my hair smell wonderful.

 

 

LUSH SOLID HENNA BAR

While the Rainbow henna necessarily comes in some kind of large container for delivery to the store, Lush solid henna bars have just a single paper label around them.

To prepare, you grate or chop the bar into pieces and mix it with boiling water.  (See instructions on bar for exact measurements.)

Lush henna bars are made with cocoa butter to condition the hair, and they are also loaded with various essential oils, herbs, and spices.  The brown bar does contain coffee and cloves — two of the ingredients I added to the Rainbow henna.  But it also contains perfume, which can include some undisclosed synthetic ingredients.  Fragrances are problematic because they can contain hormone-disrupting phthalates, and unless a company discloses all the ingredients in their fragrances, the customer has no way to know if they are safe or not.  Here is Lush’s statement about the perfumes they use.

If you want Lush to quit with the synthetics and to fully disclose the ingredients in their fragrances, please send them a message.

 APPLYING HENNA

I applied Rainbow henna to half of my head and Lush henna to the other half.  The instructions always say to wrap your head in a plastic bag, but I never do that. I just cover it with an old towel that I use specifically for this purpose.

Caveat:  You should ALWAYS wear gloves when applying henna!  Here is what happens if you don’t:

My gloves are natural rubber and cotton ones from Casabella.  Another company, If You Care, offers FSC-certified natural rubber gloves, which is even better.

I left the henna on my hair for about 2-3 hours and just went about my household chores.  If you don’t have gray hair, you can probably leave it on for a lot less time.

Later, I discovered that I could save time by just applying the henna to the gray bits without coating my entire head with it.

 

THE RESULTS

I’d say both brands of henna accomplished the same desired results: covering my gray.  But I wouldn’t buy the Lush henna again because the smell was just too strong with all the many different essential oils and perfume in it.  My simple Rainbow henna recipe smelled great and contained no synthetic chemicals.

So, if you color your hair, what plastic-free or less plastic method do you use?  I know some of you wear your gray like a badge of honor.  I salute you.  I have to confess I am not there yet.  At least not all of the time.

112 comments
LoriPoppe
LoriPoppe

I too am way too young for the amount of grey hair I have;). I am looking to make a more natural switch. How long does the Henna color last on grey hair?

LoriPoppe
LoriPoppe

I too am way too young for the amount of grey hair I have;). I am looking to make a more natural switch. How long does the Henna color last on grey hair?

Meli
Meli

I know I am very, very late to the party here, but I have just recently started henna-ing again. I use either a mix of BAQ henna and cassia, or Rainbow Light/Strawberry blonde. I have the much-maligned and evilly named "dishwater blonde" or very, very light "mousy brown" (another great name!) color.

I leave on only for one hour. In this way I achieve a caramel color leaning toward reddish. It's just the color I want and the one color I could never achieve with chemical dyes. I have just a few greys - at the temples, naturally! - and they are a more "sparkly" color.

You are a beautiful lady, you have such soulful eyes and they are an amazing color.

Chitra
Chitra

Very nice post. Now, Lush is actively showing the complete list of Ingredients on the pack. Sticking to them for now because of the convenience.

Muffazal Tikiwala
Muffazal Tikiwala

I love henna as it gives great colors and shades. I generally use sesame oil on hair before applying henna as it provides conditioning and also does not let henna stick to the hair.

Muffazal Tikiwala
Muffazal Tikiwala

I love henna as it gives great colors and shades. I generally use sesame oil on hair before applying henna as it provides conditioning and also does not let henna stick to the hair.

Sulamit
Sulamit

Forgot to mention that my hair is dark blond with some reddish highlights and I got a wonderful auburn colour with Red Henna. Now I'm in my sixties and have very long hair reaching below my buttocks. I'd love to get rid of the grey. Anyone out there with long dark blond hair using Henna? I don't want my hair to turn red. Any colour of Henna that would just add some red highlights? Any other tips?

Sulamit
Sulamit

Forgot to mention that my hair is dark blond with some reddish highlights and I got a wonderful auburn colour with Red Henna. Now I'm in my sixties and have very long hair reaching below my buttocks. I'd love to get rid of the grey. Anyone out there with long dark blond hair using Henna? I don't want my hair to turn red. Any colour of Henna that would just add some red highlights? Any other tips?

Sulamit
Sulamit

Hi! When I was young I loved to use red henna and it made my hair look wonderful. With gray hair you should be cautious, as it can turn your hair an unpleasant greenish hue. Just make a test before trying any kind of henna if your hair is gray. Your hair looks fab. I used the ordinary powdered henna like the one you bought at Rainbow.

Sulamit
Sulamit

Hi! When I was young I loved to use red henna and it made my hair look wonderful. With gray hair you should be cautious, as it can turn your hair an unpleasant greenish hue. Just make a test before trying any kind of henna if your hair is gray. Your hair looks fab. I used the ordinary powdered henna like the one you bought at Rainbow.

Araceli
Araceli

Hi Beth,

My name is Araceli. I noticed in the pictures you posted in this article that you have what seems like a reusable coffee filter. I have the same kind of coffee maker, but I haven't been able to find a reusable coffee filter that is not plastic so I have been using recycled paper ones. Do you have any suggestions? Any help will be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

BethTerry
BethTerry moderator

It would be fantastic if everyone who buys their henna from mehandi.com would contact the company and ask them to package it without plastic.  There are clear cellulose bags they could use.  Of paper bags.  One thing to be aware of is that often what looks like foil is actually mylar, another kind of plastic.

BethTerry
BethTerry

It would be fantastic if everyone who buys their henna from mehandi.com would contact the company and ask them to package it without plastic.  There are clear cellulose bags they could use.  Of paper bags.  One thing to be aware of is that often what looks like foil is actually mylar, another kind of plastic.

chicknlil
chicknlil

My hair is red, but it's more strawberry blonde and auburn would be too dark for me.  (90's Nicole Kidman)  What do I add to lighten the henna?  Where should I look for more info?  I'm not going grey, I'm getting a few white hairs and it blends in now, but someday the white hair will reach critical mass and it won't be pretty. 

Mary Hastings
Mary Hastings

Thanks Beth - I needed this. Trying to work up the courage to mix up some henna and do my hair. Got it dyed at a salon 6 months ago (brain fart!) and vowed never again. Was going to try Lush but will look into other options first - great suggestions in your comments.

Mary Hastings
Mary Hastings

Thanks Beth - I needed this. Trying to work up the courage to mix up some henna and do my hair. Got it dyed at a salon 6 months ago (brain fart!) and vowed never again. Was going to try Lush but will look into other options first - great suggestions in your comments.

Hollie-Saltwater
Hollie-Saltwater

I use henna from www.hennaforhair.com (mehandi.com), and it's beautiful. I just did an application about two weeks ago. 

 

I follow their instructions almost to the letter. One thing I do different is that I use vinegar instead of lemon juice. On the Henna For Hair website, they say to use lemon juice because vinegar will stink, but I've found that lemon juice doesn't give nearly as beautiful an application of color. I have very dark brown hair that is sometimes, in the blue-tinted cool Seattle winter light, mistaken for black. It isn't black, but it is dark. When I use henna with lemon juice, there is virtually no difference. When I use henna with vinegar (I use apple cider vinegar), it comes out deep auburn, and it's very noticeable, even in the evening light. 

 

I love what henna does for the condition of my hair, but I am tired of the color. Red hair is gorgeous, but it doesn't feel like me, I prefer the brown/black. So, I just ordered a box of henna and indigo from mehandi.com, which arrived a few days ago. I'm excited to try the addition of indigo to get my hair back to it's natural color! 

Saltwater
Saltwater

I use henna from www.hennaforhair.com (mehandi.com), and it's beautiful. I just did an application about two weeks ago. 

 

I follow their instructions almost to the letter. One thing I do different is that I use vinegar instead of lemon juice. On the Henna For Hair website, they say to use lemon juice because vinegar will stink, but I've found that lemon juice doesn't give nearly as beautiful an application of color. I have very dark brown hair that is sometimes, in the blue-tinted cool Seattle winter light, mistaken for black. It isn't black, but it is dark. When I use henna with lemon juice, there is virtually no difference. When I use henna with vinegar (I use apple cider vinegar), it comes out deep auburn, and it's very noticeable, even in the evening light. 

 

I love what henna does for the condition of my hair, but I am tired of the color. Red hair is gorgeous, but it doesn't feel like me, I prefer the brown/black. So, I just ordered a box of henna and indigo from mehandi.com, which arrived a few days ago. I'm excited to try the addition of indigo to get my hair back to it's natural color! 

Meli
Meli

@Sulamit Hey sweetie, I have a few greys and they come up a lighter, redder, more "sparkly" color. It looks like highlights. It's really a very neat look.

Hollie-Saltwater
Hollie-Saltwater

 @Sulamit Henna is just one color - it's always a red tone. Anything you see in a box that says it's a different "color of henna" means it has henna and then something else added to it to get another shade. Often these additives are things you don't want in your hair - and are responsible for the stylist who tells you that you can't do a chemical process over hennaed hair. In fact you can, it's perfectly safe, as long as you used pure henna without additives. 

 

If you go to hennaforhair.com, you can read about how to add cassia and indigo to get a different color than red. But pure henna is only ever going to tint red - the degree of red depends on what you start with (blonde would be a lot red, black hair might just have a deep auburn cast in the sun). 

Saltwater
Saltwater

 @Sulamit Henna is just one color - it's always a red tone. Anything you see in a box that says it's a different "color of henna" means it has henna and then something else added to it to get another shade. Often these additives are things you don't want in your hair - and are responsible for the stylist who tells you that you can't do a chemical process over hennaed hair. In fact you can, it's perfectly safe, as long as you used pure henna without additives. 

 

If you go to hennaforhair.com, you can read about how to add cassia and indigo to get a different color than red. But pure henna is only ever going to tint red - the degree of red depends on what you start with (blonde would be a lot red, black hair might just have a deep auburn cast in the sun). 

BethTerry
BethTerry

Woops.  It looks like that link got broken so you will have to copy and paste the whole thing, or just go to Etsy.com and search for "reusable coffee filter."

BethTerry
BethTerry moderator

Hi Araceli.  I bought a hemp coffee filter from my local food coop.  Here are some online:  http://www.cuspnaturalproducts.com/hemp_kitchen.html  Also, you can get cotton ones.  There are various Etsy sellers making reusable coffee filters and tea bags:  http://www.etsy.com/search?includes%5B0%5D=tags&q=reusable+coffee+filter&page=1&ref=related  If you order, make sure and ask them to send it to you without plastic packaging.

Hollie-Saltwater
Hollie-Saltwater

 @BethTerry Yeah, the shipping has no packing plastic (at least mine never do), but I think the packets themselves are mylar. I will send them a note. 

Saltwater
Saltwater

 @BethTerry Yeah, the shipping has no packing plastic (at least mine never do), but I think the packets themselves are mylar. I will send them a note. 

salamander
salamander

Cassia is often mixed in with henna to make it lighter. Check around the forums at longhaircommunity.com for tips!

Sulamit
Sulamit

@Saltwater You could try and mix Henna with coffee it is perfect for dark hair if you want to avoid any red accents.

Sulamit
Sulamit

@Saltwater You could try and mix Henna with coffee it is perfect for dark hair if you want to avoid any red accents.

Meli
Meli

@BethTerry @TinaWilkersonKnight Yup! I have frozen my henna many times (after dye release) and interestingly, the dye power seems stronger once it's been frozen and re-thawed. That's just me but I definitely notice this effect.

Sulamit
Sulamit

@Saltwater Thanks! When I was young there were rumours about those Henna powders giving other colours than red contained some nasty substances. I know real henna is red. I'll read about suitable additives at hennaforhair. Due to the length of my hair, I'm scared to end up with a disaster.

Sulamit
Sulamit

@Saltwater Thanks! When I was young there were rumours about those Henna powders giving other colours than red contained some nasty substances. I know real henna is red. I'll read about suitable additives at hennaforhair. Due to the length of my hair, I'm scared to end up with a disaster.

BethTerry
BethTerry

 @Saltwater  @Sulamit Right.  Both of the hennas that I used have indigo in them to make them brown. The Lush henna also has coffee. And I added coffee myself to the Rainbow henna.  

BethTerry
BethTerry moderator

Woops.  It looks like that link got broken so you will have to copy and paste the whole thing, or just go to Etsy.com and search for "reusable coffee filter."

Hollie-Saltwater
Hollie-Saltwater

 @Sulamit  I totally understand! My hair is long, and I love it and take good care of it, and the idea of damaging it in some permanent way makes me feel sick. 

 

I have a lot of confidence in the hennaforhair.com products (her shopping website is mehandi.com), and tomorrow I'll be doing an indigo/henna mix to get my now-auburn hair back to it's natural dark brown! I've never used indigo before so I'm really excited to see how it goes. :) Let us know what you choose to do with your hair! 

Hollie-Saltwater
Hollie-Saltwater

 @BethTerry  @Sulamit I just read the instruction sheet that came with my henna and indigo shipment from hennaforhair.com. I'm posting this just as a data point. It says, "Don't add coffee to your mix. That will make your hair smell bad, give you the jitters, and won't improve the color."

 

So that's her opinion on the coffee matter, but keep in mind she also says to avoid vinegar, and the only way I get great color from henna is by using vinegar! Her lemon juice recommendation doesn't work for me at all. Just goes to show we all have different experiences, eh?

 

(Also I can't imagine using coffee and having it smell bad - my husband uses a LUSH bath and shower soap that's made with coffee and he smells divine afterward.) 

Saltwater
Saltwater

 @Sulamit  I totally understand! My hair is long, and I love it and take good care of it, and the idea of damaging it in some permanent way makes me feel sick. 

 

I have a lot of confidence in the hennaforhair.com products (her shopping website is mehandi.com), and tomorrow I'll be doing an indigo/henna mix to get my now-auburn hair back to it's natural dark brown! I've never used indigo before so I'm really excited to see how it goes. :) Let us know what you choose to do with your hair! 

Saltwater
Saltwater

 @BethTerry  @Sulamit I just read the instruction sheet that came with my henna and indigo shipment from hennaforhair.com. I'm posting this just as a data point. It says, "Don't add coffee to your mix. That will make your hair smell bad, give you the jitters, and won't improve the color."

 

So that's her opinion on the coffee matter, but keep in mind she also says to avoid vinegar, and the only way I get great color from henna is by using vinegar! Her lemon juice recommendation doesn't work for me at all. Just goes to show we all have different experiences, eh?

 

(Also I can't imagine using coffee and having it smell bad - my husband uses a LUSH bath and shower soap that's made with coffee and he smells divine afterward.) 

Araceli
Araceli

 @BethTerry Thank you so much Beth, I greatly appreciate all of your help! I'll check these out. Again thanks!