The blog formerly known as   Fake Plastic Fish

May 11, 2011

Gardening Without Plastic, Part 1: Raised Beds and Plastic-Free Soil

Last Fall,’s Dana Blinder contacted me about plastic-free gardening. What she didn’t know was that I had already failed miserably in the gardening department several times and wasn’t sure gardening was my thing. That’s when we came up with a brilliant idea. Rodale would teach me how to grow an organic garden, and I would figure out how to do it with the minimum plastic possible.

My guru for this project is Rodale’s Eric Hurlock, Associate Online Editor for “Organic Gardening.” First, I sent him photos of my postage stamp front yard, the only space available for a garden. (My neighborhood in Oakland, CA, is in Zone 8B, according to the USDA Hardiness Zone Finder.)

Beth's plastic-free garden project

I explained that the yard is basically hard clay that is overrun every Spring by tough little yellow flowers that refuse to be pulled up. Each year the landlord sends some guys over to chop the weeds down, but they’re never uprooted. I’m betting the roots are taller than me at this point.

Eric suggested that instead of trying to make my hard, weedy soil hospitable to vegetables, I should build a raised bed filled with rich, organic soil on top of it. Oh dear.  I’m building now? I could see this project was going to be more complicated than buying a bunch of plants and sticking them in the ground. Still, I was committed. And I wanted to not only make this garden plastic-free but as low impact as possible. So I asked about using salvaged lumber for the frame of the raised bed instead of brand new wood.

Eric said no. For an organic garden, secondhand wood would not work because it might have been treated with toxic chemicals in its previous life, and we’d have no way of knowing. So instead I looked for new lumber certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC-certified) to be from sustainably-managed forests. I rented a pickup truck from Zip Car (the car share service I belong to so I don’t have to own a car) and scooted over to Ashby Lumber in Berkeley, which I discovered carries plenty of FSC-certified wood.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

I purchased nails from the bulk bin at the hardware store, tossing the amount I needed into a brown paper bag, which I will be sure to reuse.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Michael sawed the boards to the right length for me (my arm’s been acting up), and then I set to work building my 6′ x 4′ x 12″ box.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Beth's plastic-free garden project

But what would I put under my box to keep the weeds from coming up through the new soil I would buy? Black plastic, popular among so many gardeners, was obviously out.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Eric suggested used cardboard instead. Perfect. We have an attic full of broken down cardboard moving boxes. I used a few of those.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

And then I had to find a way to fill the box with soil without ending up with a billion plastic bags.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Some companies, like American Soil and Stone in Richmond, CA, sell soil and amendments in bulk. They can dump it into your own truck or deliver it to your door. Bright and early one Wednesday morning, a big truck pulled up loaded with “Local Hero Veggie Mix” (Contains: Sandy Loam, WonderGrow Organic Compost, Rice Hulls, Chicken Manure, Grape Compost, Fir Bark, Cocoa Bean Hulls) for me. “I hope you can use extra,” the driver said, “because I have way more than you ordered.”

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Sure! More is always better, right? Um… not if it’s Wednesday morning, and the guy dumps the dirt right in the middle of the sidewalk, and you have to shovel all of that dirt off the sidewalk before leaving for work, all the while praying that someone in a wheelchair doesn’t need the sidewalk before you’re done. But I did it. I was prepared with my shovel, as well as a wheelbarrow I had borrowed from our local tool lending library. Yep, the wheelbarrow is plastic, but according to my plastic-free rules, borrowing and sharing durable plastic goods, instead of buying new, is not just allowed, it’s encouraged.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

Beth's plastic-free garden project

I shoveled all morning until my shoveler was sore. And as you can see, I did end up with way more dirt than would fit in my little raised bed frame.

Beth's plastic-free garden project

But it turns out that that’s good. Because Eric says that I shouldn’t plant my squash or cucumbers, which tend to spread out, in the box but in mounds of their own outside the box. I’ll also use some of the dirt to grow herbs in terra cotta pots. All this talk of veggies and herbs leads me to my next plastic-free dilemmas:

1) Buying plants that don’t come in plastic pots. I can plant seeds from paper envelopes, but Eric says that I should not grow tomatoes and peppers from seeds but from seedlings.  And what about those plastic markers they inevitably come with?

2) Finding a plastic-free garden hose. Does such a thing even exist? And if not, what’s the most eco-friendly hose I can buy? Or is there a better way to water?  I haven’t found a plastic-free hose, but I have found ones that supposedly have fewer leaching chemicals.  But some people have recommended skipping the hose altogether.  One of my Facebook friends recommends ladling water from a metal bucket.  And one of the Rodale readers suggests a metal watering can.  What do you think?

3) Finding plastic-free gardening gloves. My hands were pretty calloused after all that shoveling, and my fingernails were a mess. A pair of gardening gloves would be nice, but I’m not interested in gloves made with vinyl or polyester, and I’m a vegetarian so I don’t want leather or suede either.

Do you have advice for me? I’d love to hear it.


You might also enjoy...


Feelgoodz natural flip flops

I only post ads for products I use myself. Your support helps to fund my plastic-free mission.

Leave a Reply

46 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
44 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Way to get it done! I stumbled upon this awesome resource just yesterday… Straw bales are the raised bed and the growing medium, and it builds soil in the process.

There is a free webinar on 04.10.15 from their website.


Good for you! I’m impressed and inspired!

Kelly S.

We used newspaper as a weed block on the top surface of our garden this year. (It is held down by a thin layer of mulch dropped off for free from a local tree trimming company. It seems to be working well where we made the layers thick enough. Next season we can just till it into the garden. Your space is small so a watering can might do the trick! Metal ones do last forever and you might find them at a flea market for sale. Try the one at De Anza college! It is amazing.

Jayadeep Purushothaman

We have an organic terrace garden and your post made me realize the plastic pieces in it – the bottom of the box is plastic, and there are some pots that are plastic that came with the plants we bought from a nursery – we didn’t want to throw it anyway. We didn’t buy a plastic hose(garden is small), but use a plastic water can. And we bought a pair of glows too – but decided not to use it. It was uncomfortable and latex.


Your awesome! Think I’m extra touched by this post as I’ve just started growing as well. I have caved in on the gloves though…. & I still have blisters! have you found an answer to seed potting? I’ll post a pic to your facebook of a magic machine a friend lent me.

Another friend said Goats shit is the shit! But I know it’ll come in bags… so I’m off to get loose horses from a friend instead today. Another bag saved!


Go, Beth! I am so impressed. I too am a recovering garden failure. I take great interest in your evolution. Maybe I will give it another go! Keep posting your progress, I’d love to hear it.


Regards the cost of a metal watering can – yes, they are definitely expensive, but my mum’s is still going after 15 years :)

Show me a plastic watering can that can match that record! Given that if the plastic doesn’t become brittle and crack, the nozzle will probably throw a wobbly and there’ll be no replacements to be found. (guess who’s a convert..)


Many nurseries have seedling grown in wooden flats and cut the desired number of plants out of the flat and wrap them in newspaper and twine for you to take home.


I haven’t read the comments so you may have heard already, but they make gloves that are cotton canvas-type material. You can find them all over in fact I saw some the other day with no plastic packaging, but i prefer a different kind of glove so I didn’t think much about it. As far as watering is concerned. If you can be dedicated you do not need a hose, but you will need an outdoor faucet/spigot of some sort. Get a bucket or watering can (you can find plenty of metal ones post to criagslist/freecycle/etc and i bet you’ll… Read more »


Wow! You already got all the best ideas for gloves, watering, etc. You have some awesome followers. This post is so timely for me! I too want to start a small and plastic-free garden on a postage stamp yard with clay ground. I’m thinking of doing it in 2 or 3 half-barrells for small circle gardens. I’m not there yet, as we still need to design and build our deck and fence this summer (we are using Trestlewood, repurposed wood from local old railroad trestles, which fits with the repurposing of our warehouse-house). But I got a head-start with composting… Read more »


A 10′ length of 3′ high fencing looped into a circle makes a quick, inexpensive compost bin. Keep some bags of leaves to layer with your kitchen scraps and throw on some soil once in a while and you’ll have compost in 6 months. Make sure to keep the pile moist, but not wet. Also, a cheap stainless steel stock pot with a lid makes an attractive, cleanable indoor compost bucket.

Eve Stavros

Kudos to you for all this hard work!!! I started my tomatoes from seed directly outdoors, as have thousands of gardeners for years… I use a galvanized metal watering can for my small container garden (I fill it every morning from the shower while I wait for the water to heat up, saving some water). For some really good gardening advice, information and a connection to a garden expert in your zone, check out the Beekman 1802 Garden Forum – you’ll find all kinds of help and can join the world’s largest community garden, all interested in growing heirloom seeds!… Read more »


Congratulations on all the hard work! Re gloves (which you’ve already solved) – I always buy my gloves at Farm & Fleet which I think is a midwest thing. But any serious work store is a good shot – and way cheaper than garden stores, plus I am always surprisingly able to find the really small sizes I need. Re pots./plants – while it’s not what you want, I was heartened to see that Lowe’s is now taking all the plastic planting deitris (pots, tags, etc.) back for recycling “into new pots.” Watering – you don’t need a hose or… Read more »

Brittany D

Hi! Both my mom and I thought your post about building a raised bed was great. We have had similar experiences whenever we come up with a great scheme to do something out in the garden. Regarding what to do about a hose: You have a little raised bed with some veggies on the side? You don’t need a hose. For large watering projects, I may drag out my hose, but I generally use a bucket and a “watering can” which is a tin can with nail holes punched in it to get a nice rainlike effect on greens and… Read more »


The plastic tray pots that I get at the greenhouses are encouraged to be washed and returned. I don’t feel so guilt about buying tomatoes that way anymore. Peppers won’t grow here whether you start them from seed or get a pot so its kind of hopeless to try. Gloves: I like the rubberized farm gloves; but the rubber is probably not real rubber. They are cloth gloves dipped in a coating on the front half. I probably go through a pair each year, but they work so d-m good (gripping thistles without being poked, gripping dandelions to pull up… Read more »

Amy Korst

Some posters have already beat me to it, but I return the plastic pots I can’t use back to the nursery they came from. I try to buy my starts from a farmer’s market, and the farmers are always happy to have pots returned to them. You’ll probably find that having some pots on hand can be handy, though, if you really get into gardening. I start most of my seeds, including peppers and tomatoes, and as they grow, I transplant them into bigger and bigger plastic pots until they graduate to the raised beds outside. I reuse the pots… Read more »


I no longer use gloves. If callouses are your concern you’ve done the bulk of the hard work. If dirt is the issue…I almost feel like saying then don’t garden…my point is you don’t need them after you start the garden. Can’t help with the hose thing. But my first year I hauled water from the spigit to the plants…so depending on the distance you can do that…double whamy..excersie and gardening. I grow my squash and cucumbers on rebar….so it grows up over the arch of the rebar…ez rot……saves space…reuseable…metal…and pretty….last year I place cucumbers on one side and… Read more »


1. Check with local greenhouses. I’m sure someone will let you transplant plants into your own containers and then reuse the plastic pots. Our local greenhouse LOVES when you bring pots back because it helps them keep cost down. 2. For a garden that small, a hose would be overkill. If there’s a tap outside, I think a metal watering can would be just perfect. 3. Gloves are easy. Most hardware stores carry gloves made of canvas. Look for “work” gloves instead of gardening gloves. The tricky part will be finding them without one of those little plastic hangers. Glad… Read more »


I think there are also canvas flat-laying (sans water) hoses, like what the firemen use. But I agree with the above; unless holding a water can is bad on your arm, it will be much easier for such a small plot. The hose would be overkill, and the watering can is gentler, too, on little transplants.


1. I’ve grown both peppers and tomatoes from seed. The tomatoes I had started early indoors and made those newspaper pots for them. The peppers I started in the ground but didn’t get as big as they could have if I had started them earlier indoors. 2. I have an old rubber hose that my parents passed on to me. It doesn’t look good, it has discolouration of black spots on it but otherwise it works perfectly, you just have to make sure to drain it well and bring it in (cold garage is ok) before any water freezes in… Read more »

Sandra Pawula

Amazing! I use a watering can for watering most of the time. I do have plastic hoses leftover from the previous owners. I also have cotton gloves, but they do wear out quickly. Soil is the biggest challenge for me as it’s not easy to get organic soil in bulk where I live.

Good luck! I’m looking forward to seeing what comes up.

Madeline Houston

I love all the tips on doing without plastic in the garden! My idea for getting water to your raised bed is using flexible metal pipes. Fittings would hold them together. Look at the plumbing materials at your hardware store to fit everything together. Since the pipes are flexible, you would shape them For the ends, you could get fittings so that one end hooks to your faucet and the other end has a fitting so you could attach a small metal sprinkler that would water your garden. Alternatively, you could create a soaker hose-type set-up using flexible metal pipes… Read more »


Congratulations on your new garden! Lots of good advice from others here. Mel Bartholomew (author of The New Square Foot Garden & to whom I have no connection whatsoever), actually recommends using a cup dipped in a bucket to water your plants. He gives lots of reasons for this in the book. It’s an excellent how-to for first time, raised bed gardeners. Your local library should have a copy; just make sure to get the NEW version. Best of luck in your new adventure!

Sandi Ratch

The above company sells beautiful metal watering cans – we can also buy them at Lee Valley.

Growing tomatoes from seed isn’t easy (not sure what people mean when they say “easy” – tomatoes are tricky), but it can be done. However, you need to start them a good 10 weeks before the last frost in your area – if you get any. If not, you can grow them from seed at any time.

Good luck with it all.


Thank you so much for this post Beth! I dream of a garden some day (once I have more space than just a fire escape!) and I know I’ll be referring back to this post for tips on a plastic free garden! :) So have you decided what you’re going to plant? :)


I can’t wait to see how your little garden turns out- I have such a black thumb but your story is very inspiring. When I had a garden it was too far to reach with a hose, so I used a metal watering can and bucket.


Good on you Terry for taking this on!! With your tiny garden it would be viable to skip the hose and just use a watering can, I have a metal one that I love that I picked up at the local hardware store. The same place I got my all cotton gloves. For plastic free transplants please check your local farmers’ market. I grow many seedling more than I need each year and sell my extras off at the market, there my well be someone at your local market doing the same. For pea fencing and tomato cages I use… Read more »

Kanna Jones

Wow. So, it is a production of oil. That’s disappointing. Thank you for your investigation.

Jessica | Cloth Diapering Mama


Where there is a will there is a way..and you certainly have the WILL! Thanks for showing us that anything can be done if you put your mind and your determination to it. Can’t wait to see pics when its nice and full of sustainable goodies!!!

Five Seed

I’ve had the same problems with hoses and gloves – have yet to find any that are plastic-free! But I’m doing good with no plastic in the garden. I am frustrated by the seedlings, though – I buy a few for tomatoes each year and while they are in paper pots (which decompose in the soil) THOSE are wrapped in plastic!! Why, why, why? Just throw some burlap around it and I’m good! Frustrating. We should start writing to the seedling companies and ask for plastic-free packaging!


What an exciting, and potentially delicious, experiment! I’m sure you could find a nursery or farmer’s market grower that would let you bring seedlings home in your own container, or at least return the pots for repurposing. Since you’ve got just a small plot, I don’t think you’d need to get a hose at all. My grandmother watered every flower bed on her large property from the rain barrel and had gorgeous flowers and veggies every year. She had a plastic watering can to use though. I bet you could get or even make one in metal or wood! I’m… Read more »

Kanna Jones

Great, Beth. Now you need some massage!
Cowpots sound perfect, but it’s probably against veganism. I mentioned before, but it’s sometimes hard to be Vegan and plastic free at the same time.
Regarding the garden hose, I use a rubber hose and I thought that it was 100% rubber. It’s not?
Old fashion cotton knitted gloves are 100% cotton. Avoid the ones that have dots because those are PVC.
I can’t wait to see your fresh vegetables right from your garden!


1. I say soak seeds overnight and plant if you are stuck without a plastic-free option. Some places grow seedlings in reused plastic pots. 2. I use a metal watering can, and get the water from my city supplied recycled plastic rain barrel. Watering cans let you water gently and evenly. Water the soil, not the plants. Tomatoes hate getting water on them directly. 3. Used gloves, cloth gloves. Cotton gloves are really cheap at hardware stores. Newspaper works as landscape fabric, too. I’d use reused wood, just not any that was green (treated) or painted. For new I’d buy… Read more »


This is such a great post! We plant a vegetable garden every year, and I have a ‘salad table’ built for me by my husband where I grow herbs. Alas, we didn’t try for plastic-free this year, but I am planning on it next year!


Actually, a quick google reveals that some companies do still make rubber garden hoses, although I can’t promise that it won’t come with some plastic. And, as Ivy said, many veggie plants can be found in pressed peat pots that you can plant directly in the ground (although I always strip them off first because I think they restrict the roots, but they will biodegrade if you just cover them with dirt.) That leaves those pesky little plastic labels — which I guess you’ll just have to slip into someone else’s plants before leaving the nursery…. Happy gardening! You are… Read more »


When I was little we had a huge garden, and a small well – so using a hose to water was out of the question. My parents had a 50 gallon metal drum to catch rain water (the downspouts from the house all fed into it) and we would dunk our watering cans/buckets into that and take them down to the garden to water the plants.

Any local farmers or nurseries willing to share seedlings they started themselves, so you wont have to buy ones in plastic flats?


Tomatoes and peppers are super easy to grow from seed, and in your growing zone it’s not like it’s too late to start them now. (It would be in my “tropical” zone 5.) I start seedlings in biodegradable pots that you can plant with the seedling.

This whole thing will be an experiment, it is for me too and this is my 3rd year container / raised bed gardening. Just remember to try things out and don’t worry too much about your final harvest. It’s a learning experience so you just have to find out what will work for you!


Great post, thanks! So exciting that you’re still finding new things to write about. It sounds like people have you covered on the gloves and the seedlings (though a farmers market might be another option for seedlings), so I just wanted to vote that I really doubt you’d even need a hose for such a small area. I’d look for a large (used?) metal watering can.


What’s with the not growing tomatoes and peppers from seed? Just curious. My neighbor does this all the time, and I am growing them from seed this year too. Is it a matter of timing at this point?

Laurie Meyerpeter

1. Next year, grow your own seedlings in wooden flats, clay pots, or cans with holes punched in the bottom with an old fashioned can opener. This year, look for seedlings in those paper-pulp pots or other types of non-plastic pots. Many places have these. Or ask friends or garden clubs if they have extras. Most people who grow seedlings, grow extras. Or try Craig’s List. 2. As far as I know, there are no readily available plastic-free hoses. I use a high quality synthetic rubber hose (Goodyear or Sears are examples) and then repair them with a hose repair… Read more »


At the Oakland Whole Foods, I’ve seen plants outside in degradable eco-containers, rather than plastic pots. I’ve seen that around a lot of places, actually… you might not have as hard a time as you might imagine.


How do you feel about vintage leather or suede? I don’t like to buy new things made with leather, but old things don’t bother me too much since they aren’t newly manufactured. I figure if they already exist, what’s the harm? You might feel differently, of course, but I thought I’d throw that out there just in case.


Ah, and a quick google search of “all canvas gardening gloves” came back with several options that would seem likeiy to work just fine for you. Many are available with PVC dots “for gripping” but that should be pretty easy to avoid.



I have all canvas gardening gloves but I don’t have any idea where they came from. My mom got them for me years ago. I assume at a hardware store though, so it might be worth asking.

They can be a little difficult to keep on without any elastic at the wrist, but for the most part they work just fine.

Happy gardening! I’m excited to see how this works out for you.

Laura A.

I’m so glad you’re doing this! I also have a raised bed garden (one in a box frame and a few more in raised mounds) and have encountered the same dilemmas. I’ll be watching carefully. I grow my seedlings biodegradable, wrapped in cardboard Cow Pots ) and label them with wooden sticks (glorified popsicle sticks, bought from bulk bin).