The blog formerly known as   Fake Plastic Fish

September 16, 2013

What’s Your Advice for Plastic-free, Natural, Mosquito Bite Remedy?

imageSo, I kind of screwed up. I brought a tin of Chagrin Valley bug repellent with me to Hawaii, intending to use it and review it on this blog. (We don’t really have too many biting bugs in the Bay Area, so I hadn’t had a chance to try it.)

It seems great. Comes in a metal tin and contains only Organic Virgin Shea Butter; Organic Jojoba oil; Organic Unrefined Beeswax; Organic Neem oil; Organic Essential oils of Lemon Eucalyptus, Cedarwood, Citronella, Lavender, Rosemary, Lemongrass, Basil, Thyme.

Yesterday, Michael and I were only planning to hang out in town, so I didn’t bother applying the bug repellant,
but we ended up driving up to see Wailua Falls. The falls were pretty from a distance, but I noticed people standing at the top of the falls and thought, if they can do that, why can’t we?


So we looked for a path, and found one… with a sign saying, “Area Closed. Danger. Steep Cliff. You Will Die If You Take This Path!! For Real.” So of course, that’s the way we decided to go.  I took off my flip flops so I could grip the dirt with my toes, and down we went.

No sooner were we half way down the “cliff” then I noticed lots of little flying things around my feet. They didn’t whine like mosquitoes, and we were already halfway down, so I just said to myself, “Screw it,” and ignored them.

We made it to the top of the falls!




And then headed back.



Coming back, we chose an even steeper, more treacherous route and ended up getting separated at the top in fields of dense, high grasses that were over our heads. I notice I didn’t take any pix during that part… more interested in finding the road and each other and not dying.

That night, we celebrated our success at coming through our little adventure unscathed. I didn’t notice the scathedness of my ankles and feet until early this morning when I woke up itching like crazy. Holy cow.


Yep, those bugs were definitely mosquitoes. So I Googled “natural mosquito bite remedies” to figure out what I could do at 5am in a hotel room with things I already had. This article from The Healthy Home Economist, and especially the long list of comments at the end, gave me hope. The most promising solutions seemed to be banana peel rubbed on the bites (which we had bought earlier at a local farmers market), apple cider vinegar (brought for conditioning hair), or baking soda (brought for deodorant and washing hair.)

I tried the banana peel solution last night, and believe it or not, it worked! The itching mostly subsided right away.


I tried apple cider vinegar this morning, and it felt good going on, but the itching came back pretty quickly. So I used more banana peel, and right now my legs feel pretty good… as long as I don’t touch them.

Another solution recommended often is tea tree oil, but I didn’t bring any with me. I will next time I travel. What advice do you have for soothing itchy mosquito bites without using something in a plastic bottle or tube?

I’ll be using the bug repellent every time I go out now, but I probably can’t give you a real review since I’m already covered in bites.

You might also enjoy...


ECOlunchbox - Green and Healthy Lunchboxes for People & Planet

I only post ads for products I use myself. Your support helps to fund my plastic-free mission.

Leave a Reply

26 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
18 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

The simplest solution is the best: hot water. As hot as you can stand without burning yourself. The actual scientific reason why this is effective is that the cells in your body that produce histamine (the immune system chemical that stimulates inflammation) have a limited output rate. The addition of heat overstimulates the cells in that area and makes them dump their payload too fast. So when you’re running hot water over the area, there will be a temporary increase in itching – if you grit your teeth through that, then you should experience a decrease in itching soon after.… Read more »


I read somewhere that a type of geranium/pellargonium (sp.?) can deter mozzies. You scrunch the leaves up and its oil comes out – rub it on.
Also, methylated spirits (container? Is metho bad for the environment?) STOPPED the sting of a wasp I was bitten by many years ago – an old wives’ remedy.


I don’t have a suggestion, but I am appreciating all of the submissions. So interesting!


I like to use ice cubes made w whole milk. but be sure not to get ice burn. it soothes and brings down inflammation. Luv all the great tips! keep em comin.


Beth Terry It snuck up on us but I may come! I’ve let all the Down to Earth’s know, as they are all about that. Anyone have a room they want to split? Let me know.. (you can text or call me too if needed)

Beth Terry

Hi Malena. We’re on Kauai. I’ll be on Oahu on Friday. Are you coming???


Something you can buy anywhere, as soon as you get off the plane for about $1.00: Ammonia! It’s a sure fire cure for mosquito bites. Use the toilet paper in your room or pack some cotton balls in you luggage because you know you just might need them! Get them good and wet and you’ll never feel them again!
Good Luck on your next adventure!
Lori from Montana


Beth! Our 1st aid balm works in Glass: Taylor’s OR BALM! Baby Diaper Balm…you can get it at Down to Earth..are you on Oahu yet? I can bring you some, but they might be gone by then. Also, our SHUE BUG, I could send to you in glass with a metal cap..let me know! I didn’t know you were already in Hawaii, but we make stuff that WORKS, since we live here!

Beth Terry

Mark, we drove all the way up to pu’u o kila lookout yesterday and Michael acknowledged the existence of god. Today, we did a boat tour of the napali coast and snorkeled off the boat. Will post pix on Facebook.

Chelsea Gale

I’ve had friends tell me that lavender oil works. Ice might be helpful to numb and reduce inflammation, at least temporarily. Good luck!


Mint toothpaste works great. Takes the itch away and then they heal fast. I use Tom’s of Maine and have for many years but the old Crest (Ick!) and others also worked when i was a kid. If you have mint growing at your home, you can also crush some leaves (or chew on them a moment), apply and wrap some gauze around to keep it on like a poultice for a bit until the itch really goes away.


I remember that sign when I was there. Too chicken to be a scofflaw and hang out in the falls. Hope the itching stops soon. Have you been up to Moklele and the Kalalau lookout yet?


I just use a fresh lemon (cut, obviously!) and rub it on the bites!


I use Witch Hazel and/or Tea Tree oil – works every time.


Many itch remedies contain ammonia, so you could use that. I did see one that combines baking soda and ammonia into a paste. Or you could pee on yourself, I guess.

Diana Leigh Waldron

Maybe they don’t bite through pants where YOU live, lucky you!

Cory at Aquarian Bath

A few years ago one of my customers told me that my Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon Balm takes the itch out of bites, so I started trying it and it really works. Helped my brother also who was going mad itching a bunch of nasty bites on his leg.


This is hard advice to follow and admittedly doesn’t always work, but the more I scratch moquito bites, the more they itch, especially in the beginning. If I can ignore them, they stop itching and go away much faster. So if the banana peel works, do that and resist scratching them!!

Heather Itzla

a) Do NOT scratch them – pat them if you must and b) I found this one on Pinterest and it really worked for me: place a spoon in hot water for a few seconds (enough to get the spoon hot, and then place it directly on the bite until the spoon cools – supposedly it breaks down the proteins that play some factor in the itchiness – whatever the science, it’s my go-to bite-cure — Good luck and don’t scratch (looks like that suggestion might be too late… :)


I’ve had good luck with hydrogen peroxide. The sooner it’s applied the better

Melissa Brown

Cover up. Mosquitos don’t bite through pants. I think light colors are best. The EWG has tips too.


Also try peppermint essential oil for bite-relief.


It’s been a long time since I had to fight off mosquitoes in the woods, I don’t know what I’d use to fend them off. At home I just use Mexican vanilla, full strength. I put about 1/2 teaspoon in the palm of my hand and rub my hands together and then rub this all over my exposed legs and arms. It works great for me and smells so much better than that commercial stuff.

Laura Cerezo Cobos

Doesn’t work for me :(

Rita Desnoyers-Garcia

lavendar oil (therapeutic grade)

Petra Nass

Advice from my dermatologist for fresh mosquito bites: she told me that you should let warm water run over them (should be warmer than your normal body temperature, but be careful not to burn your skin!). Just take a very warm shower, maybe 3 to 5 minutes. She explained that the chemical stuff the mosquitos inject when they bite is sensitive to heat and disintegrates (not sure if that’s the right word?). In any case, what’s left afterwards is supposed not to cause the allergic reaction which leads to the itching red spots. I’ve tried it a few times and… Read more »