<< Previous Post:
Next Post: >>

November 14, 2007

Target, Multi-Pure, my Cupboards, and the Perils of PVC

 

By now, many of you have heard that after a national campaign by the Center for Health, Environment and Justice (CHEJ), Target has agreed to systematically reduce its use of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) plastic (aka vinyl) in products and packaging it carries in its stores.  Blogger LifeLessPlastic wrote a letter to Target to show her support for this action, and I have done the same. It’s always a good idea to let companies know when we appreciate the things they do. Here’s a link to Target’s online contact form if you’d like to send your own message.

Coincidentally, I had my own little PVC panic this past week when I discovered that the tubing used in my new Multi-Pure counter top water filter system, which I bought in place of the Brita we had been using, is made from virgin PVC.


As I wrote on October 29, I was already somewhat disenchanted with Multi-Pure because of the volume of plastic bubble wrap in which the unit and filter cartridge were wrapped. But it wasn’t until the unit was installed and working that I actually read the fine print and discovered the more serious problem of PVC used in the product itself.

When I called Multi-Pure to address this issue, I was told that the tubing had been tested by NSF and found not to leach anything harmful into the water. However, the rep was unable to confirm whether phthalates such as DEHP, the chemicals that are the biggest worry, were included in the list of possible contaminants for which to be tested. But regardless of whether or not this particular tubing is leaching anything harmful into my water, I decided to send the unit back anyway.

So what’s the big deal about PVC? And if the tubing’s been tested and found not to leach, why send it back? Here’s a rundown of the problems of PVC:

    1. PVC is the only major plastic that contains chlorine, so it is unique in the hazards it creates. During production, PVC plants can release dioxins which harm workers and community members who live nearby. According to pvcinformation.org, residents of Louisiana, which is home to half the PVC production facilities in the USA, have been shown to have much higher concentrations of dioxins in their blood than the average U.S. citizen.

 

 

 

  • According to ecocycle.org, because so many different additives are used to make PVC, recycling the plastic is extremely difficult, and any PVC bottles (#3 plastic) that make it into the recycling stream can contaminate and ruin a whole load of #1 bottles.

 

 

  • When incinerated, PVC forms dioxins, a highly toxic group of chemicals that build up in the food chain. When landfilled, PVC poses significant long-term environmental threats as chemical additives can leach into groundwater.

 

 

  • Greenpeace says that in a house fire, fire-retardant PVC will smolder for long periods of time rather than burn, “giving off hydrogen chloride gas long before visible signs of fire appear. Hydrogen chloride gas is a corrosive, highly toxic gas that can cause skin burns and severe long-term respiratory damage.” For this reason, the International Association of Firefighters supports alternative materials to replace PVC.

 

 

  • In fact, according to Greenpeace’s hierarchy of plastics, PVC is the very worst, even worse than Styrofoam! For a more in-depth analysis of the problems associated with PVC, please read Greenpeace’s article, “The Poison Plastic.”

 

Whether or not the tubing in the Multi-Pure system actually leaches pthalates into my water, I don’t want to support the production of a material that is so harmful to humans and the environment in general. So this morning, I shipped the Multi-Pure unit back to the company.

And then tonight, after reading that PVC cannot be recycled, and realizing that I had included several #3 Act fluoride rinse bottles in my recycling in the last few months, I went through my cupboards and refrigerator to see if there were any other PVC culprits still lurking in the house. Sure enough, I found four of them:


#3 PVC bottles look very similar to clear #1 PETE bottles. In fact, many manufacturers have switched to #1 plastic as an alternative to PVC. The only way to tell is to look at the number on the bottom of the container. #3 means PVC. Unfortunately, it’s not so easy to tell when other, unlabelled products are made from PVC. These can include children’s toys, shower curtains, window blinds, flooring, pipes, house siding, insulation, roofing membranes, protective pipes for electricity and telecom cables, casings for electronics, refrigerator gaskets, power cords, carpets, furniture, the inside of screw caps, shoes and boots, purses and luggage, raincoats, T-shirts with plastisole prints, packing tape, vinyl records, the covering on ring binders, strollers, garden furniture, tarps, car interiors, and more.

So, what do we do with PVC that we already have? The CHEJ report “PVC: Bad News Comes in 3s. The Poison Plastic, Health Hazards, and the Looming Waste Crisis“ recommends either disposing of it at a hazardous waste facility or sending it back to the manufacturer and letting them know that PVC is an unacceptable material for them to be using. For the four items I found tonight, I think I’ll go on a research mission and see if these products are still being sold in #3 bottles. (Act fluoride rinse, by the way, is now contained in #1 PETE.) If the bottles are no longer #3 plastic, I’ll just toss these current containers into my hazardous waste bag for later. But if the products are still being sold in PVC bottles, I’ll send these back to the manufacturers with a nice note.

Now once again, I am without a water filter. What to do? Well, how about something I should have done a long, long time ago: testing the water to see if we even need a water filter in the first place! Last week I purchased a Culligan water test kit at Ace Hardware and did some preliminary home tests. Turns out, our chlorine and chloramine levels are much lower than I expected! I mailed a water sample away this morning to be tested for lead. If that test comes back okay, I think we’ll drink our water unfiltered and save a whole lot of money and plastic. Imagine drinking water straight from the faucet again, just like we did as kids. What a nice idea.



Print Print

 

<< Previous Post:
Next Post: >>

Comments

A Note about leaving comments: I switched to the LifeFyre comment system because it weeds out the hundreds of spam comments I was getting each day and also allows us to respond to individual comments, to "Like" comments, and to link them to social media if we so desire. But if you do not wish to login via social media, you don't have to. You can comment without logging in! Here's how:

  1. Type your comment in the box.
  2. Click "Post Comment As" button.
  3. When the LiveFyre box pops up, type a name, email address, and optional website address in the fields provided.
  4. Click Next.
  5. LiveFyre will ask you for a user name and password. But if you don't want to register or use a password, you don't have to. Just click "Post as Guest" which is to the left of the black "Finish" button. Your comment will be saved.
  6. Please email me if you have questions or problems. This new system is supposed to make it easier for all of us to converse, not harder.
14 comments
mdnssndcvlztn
mdnssndcvlztn

Tetrahydrofuran (a known carcinogen in animals) has been known to leach from PVC and cannot be effectively filtered with carbon. also, anybody tried retrofitting their Multi-pure with flexible stainless steal? any success?

Fake Plastic Fish
Fake Plastic Fish

Hi Demetria. First, you could put your tap water through reverse osmosis if you're concerned about those chemicals. Because actually, what do you know about the chemicals leaching into the water from the plastic water bottle?Did you know that all soft plastic contains chemical additives called plasticizers to make it soft? Many of these additives are hormone disruptors. In fact, there are links between the chemicals in plastic bottles and breast cancer.Plastics contain other types of additives as well. Do we know what they are? Usually not. Because manufacturers are not required to disclose the chemical "recipes" for their plastics. The type of plastic (PET, for example) does not tell you this either.These days, I don't want to eat or drink anything that comes into contact with plastic. I'll stick with our tap water that is much more strictly regulated than bottled water in the first place. I'm not willing to turn over the quality of my drinking water to a few private corporations when clean drinking water should be a public trust for all of us.

Demetria W
Demetria W

Hi,I think that there's a trade off between drinking unfiltered or filtered tap water and bottled water, because recent reports have shown that a lot of municipal water supplies are contaminated with residual chemicals from prescription drugs, which is something that would not show up on a home water test kit. Based on this, I have personally opted for bottled water from a natural source, that has gone through a reverse osmosis process - packaged in a #1 plastic bottle. Just some food for thought.

Laura
Laura

Thank You Lex, Multi-Pure filters really are the best (no other water filter reduces more contaminants)As for the pvc plastic tubing, I would like to know what Beth herself would recommend. Then, maybe I could make a suggestion to the good folks at Multi-Pure to see what we could do about this situation. I do not know a lot about plastics, but I'm sure Beth would be able to make some sort of recommendation for us. Maybe surgical rubber tubing? I would love for her to contact me and let me know what she would suggest, so I could talk to MP about it.If anyone else has any suggestions, please feel free to contact me at admin@purestdrinkingwater.comThanks again for your concerns, and consideration.Laura Newtonwww.purestdrinkingwater.com

lex
lex

I have same multipure filter and I also questioned the PVC, altho I am still using the filter, I wish they'd use something else for the tubing. You could switch the tubing or get a local plumber to. Or, you could undersink mount the filter. Still the best filters I've found.Now people are starting to use plastic tubing instead of copper in homes, plastic seems to be getting bigger all the time. I'm glad to see you questioning its use!

Laura
Laura

In Response to Dedee.. I have in no way perpetuated "false information" intentionally or unintentionally. I personally did not know about the dangers of pvc until I found Beth's wonderful site.It is sites like hers that help to inform the public & I thank her for bringing it to our attention.In response to the pvc issue, I myself have brought this to the attention of the recently started "green team" over at Multi-Pure, and they will be looking into alternatives to the pvc tubing that is currently being utilized. Although the pvc tubing poses no danger from the stand point of the drinking water that comes into contact with the tubing. The tap water is drawn from the faucet, then through the tubing, and then filtered through a solid carbon block filter then out through the top of the filter faucet."see photo here" http://www.fakeplasticfish.com/2007/11/target-multi-pure-my-cupboards-and.htmlAs an independent distributor For Multi-Pure corporation I can assure you that Multi-Pure stands 100% behind their claims & carry the absolute finest filter available in the market. Multi-Pure is very conscientious with regards to the environment & strive to The highest standards and is dedicated to meeting the needs of all its customers. You are welcome to contact them direct with your concerns at multipure.com If you wish to contact me, you are welcome to do so at admin@purestdrinkingwater.comThanks,Laura

deedee
deedee

@LauraPVC is toxic PERIOD and there is ample evidence of this fact.I can not believe anyone who sells any kind of health product would make excuses for something so obviously wrong. You only raise suspicion of your product and your credibility.Instead of perpetuating false information, why not help customers find alternatives such as polyethylene, which is much safer and not that much more expensive. Why not offer a choice for those of us who know better?PVC production is a scourge on humanity and should be banned.http://www.checnet.org/HEALTHEHOUSE/education/articles-detail.asp?Main_ID=185

Laura Newton
Laura Newton

Beth, I am an independent distributor for Multi-Pure water filters. Have you thought about this? How many millions of plastic water bottles are multi-pure keeping out of landfills by converting people from bottled water to filtered tap water?The small amount of pvc, that multi-pure filters use will last for years! & will bio-degrade. A plastic water bottle takes 1000 years to bio-degrade.While I understand your concern about the pvc, the alternative (drinking bottled water) far outweighs the risk of pvc. AND if any chemicals leach from the pvc, it is filtered by the carbon block filter. (which is made from coconut shell carbon & is economically friendly)Laura http://www.purestdrinkingwater.comP.S. Watch for Multi-Pure's debut on planet green channels BATTLEGROUND EARTH Tonite at 10 pm Eastern..Multi-Pure's drinking water systems will be featured in a nationally televised reality series called BATTLEGROUND EARTH. The show is airing on a new network called Planet Green, which is a sister network of the Discovery Channel Check your local cable or satellite provider for the channel listing.

cynematic
cynematic

hi beth,thanks for your comment over at my blog Pillowbook about the Klean Kanteen. love your site; it's so meticulously researched and i'm glad you let companies know when they're doing something right and wrong.such terrible news about the oil spill in the bay--i used to live in oakland so i can only imagine the local response.

Rejin L
Rejin L

As always, I am amazed by the amount of research you do.I keep hearing that New York's is one of the best tap waters around, yet we filter anyway. Now that I've found out that Clorox is Brita's parent company (ironic?), I think it may be time to kick the filter habit.

heather t
heather t

Thanks! I emailed a nice note to Target. :)

Sunny
Sunny

I wonder what happens to our #3's. Our waste company and county tell us to put them into the recycling bin. Perhaps I'll look into that further. They already think I'm a nut but who cares. Thanks again for your blog.

Anonymous
Anonymous

So I tried to leave a comment on your blog but it kept telling me it couldn’t leave one. But I was just saying that at first I was afraid to read this because I LOVE my target and I was scared that you were going to report something bad on them (although…boyfriend has said that they are republican based and that he’s heard they wont do birth control prescriptions at the pharmacy…although I have never heard anything official on that…but along those lines I know that Walgreens wont do birth control prescriptions. My very good friend tried to get hers filled at a Walgreens and the pharmacist refused to do it after giving her a super long lecture on how she shouldn’t be using it and how she shouldn’t be having sex…I mean seriously…that alone keeps me from shopping at Walgreens! did i mention that this only happened two years ago and she was in her early 20's so it wasnt like she was some 14 year old girl trying to get her prescription filled...but even so they should still fill it). and my water filter still leaks. Do you think if I put caulk around it that would be…dangerous? ALSO…I think you should blog about beauty products. Because many of us out there use them but it’s often times hard to find products that are 1. all natural and organic and 2. doesn’t come in plastic bottles. For one…I use Jonathan hair products because they are a higher quality salon product and I DO notice a difference in my hair when I use them…but also his line is completely vegan and does not test on animals…only celebrities. (well he has ONE pomade that is not vegan because it uses beeswax). So I love the fact that his line is vegan…but it all comes in plastic bottles. When I went to sephora yesterday EVERYTHING…hair products, makeup products all had some kind of plastic. I’ve gone on this crazy “organic & natural” binge for products lately after reading a scary article about lead in makeup and chemicals in products (duh! But I never really thought about it) and how day after day for years you are just rubbing chemicals into your hair and head, your skin, etc! but I was curious about how you solve your beauty products. (you may have blogged more in depth about this but im too lazy to review your entire blog for that. If you did just let me know where in the blog to search for that). FYI..i saw the stuff about Lush. I need things that are scent free and dye free for super sensitive skin. :((and it still wont let me leave a message as signing in so maybe it will work under anonymous!)*marika

The Green Cat
The Green Cat

In NYC we recycle #1 and #2 small-necked plastic bottles. I never really thought to check the numbers to see if I am throwing in #3s. Thanks for pointing that out!

Post Popularity Graphing by Knowledge Ring